En 179 smart lock RFQ clause: clause language for an EN 179 smart lock RFQ that names the document, the product variant and the date, so suppliers answer.

Publicado el: nov. 09, 2022

Escape Devices in a Smart Lock RFQ: Drafting the EN 179 Clause So It Can Be Answered

Escape Devices in a Smart Lock RFQ: Drafting the EN 179 Clause So It Can Be Answered

Most EN 179 clauses written into a smart lock RFQ are one line long and cannot be answered. "The lock shall comply with EN 179" names a standard, a verb and nothing else: not which document demonstrates the requirement, not which object that document covers, not who is bound by it. Three suppliers can read that line and send three different things — a brochure page, a test report on a sample, a third-party certificate for the exact variant quoted — and only one of those is defensible when an approving authority asks what the lock on that door is.

Direct answer. An EN 179 smart lock RFQ clause is finished when it names five things: the requirement, the document that evidences it, the object the document covers, the party bound to supply it, and the point in the programme at which it must exist. This transcript builds that clause set turn by turn, from the template line a buyer inherits through to the covering note that goes out with the request for quotation. Each turn ends in an annotation stating the clause being drafted, the question the buyer is really asking, and the document to demand.

This is written for the procurement manager who owns the request for quotation and who will be held to the evidence afterwards, by a consultant, an approving authority or an internal auditor.

The conversation below is illustrative. It assembles commonly-reported buyer experience into a plausible exchange between two roles, and it is not a record of any real meeting, project, company, supplier or authority.

How this transcript works

Two voices appear. "Procurement" is the buyer writing the request for quotation. "Technical" is a standards and hardware reviewer who reads quotations for a living, in the buying organisation, in the consultant's practice, or at the factory on the other side of the table.

VoiceStands forAnswers wellCannot answer
ProcurementThe person who issues the request for quotation and owns the evidence afterwardsWhat the programme is buying, which doors are in scope, what the supplier must hand over, when it is dueWhether a document the supplier sent actually demonstrates the clause you wrote
TechnicalA reviewer who reads standards, test reports and declarations against clausesWhat a clause must bind, which document proves what, where a scope boundary sitsWhether a particular door in a particular building will be accepted by the approving authority

Three notations run through the transcript. Clause C1 to C15 are the numbered clauses that accumulate as the conversation proceeds, collected in one table further down. Annotation blocks state what a turn produces. Evidence to demand blocks name the document that must exist before a clause is satisfied.

One rule governs everything that follows. A standard describes what a standard tests. It never speaks for a factory. Conformity is always somebody's claim, evidenced by a document with a holder, a scope and a date. The question behind a clause is never "is this standard good enough" but "which document, held by whom, covering which object, on which date, am I willing to rely on". Against the catalogue, start from the smart door locks.

sequenceDiagram
    participant Buyer
    participant Adviser
    participant Supplier
    Buyer->>Adviser: Clause line inherited from the RFQ template
    Adviser->>Buyer: Five questions every clause must answer
    Buyer->>Adviser: Rewritten clause naming the document type
    Adviser->>Buyer: Object of the evidence and the production site
    Buyer->>Supplier: Clause sheet and evidence schedule issued
    Supplier->>Buyer: Evidence pack returned with gaps in it
    Buyer->>Adviser: Pack graded against The evidence-strength ladder for en 179 smart lock rfq clause runs: Rung reached and the next question to ask

Turn 1 — The clause that arrived with the template

Procurement: The request for quotation went out last week using our standard template. Line 12 of the product requirements table reads "Lock shall comply with EN 179". Three responses are back and none tells me the same thing: one sent a leaflet, one a test report for a different product family, one a certificate number with no scope attached. What do I do with the line?

Technical: You have three suppliers optimising for three different readings of it, and they are all reading it correctly, which is the problem. That clause contains no document type, so a leaflet satisfies it. It contains no object, so a certificate for another family satisfies it. It contains no holder, so a number with no scope satisfies it.

Procurement: So the clause is weak rather than the suppliers being difficult?

Technical: The clause is weak, and the suppliers are behaving exactly as you taught them to. Delete the line rather than repair it in place, because a half-repaired line still reads as "comply with EN 179" at the top of the table and quietly overrides whatever you add underneath. What goes in its place is six components: what is required, in words that could be checked; which document evidences it, named by type; what object it covers, down to model designation and variant; who is bound to produce it; when it must exist relative to the order; and what happens if it does not exist. Write those six and you have a clause. Leave one out and you have a sentence.

Annotation — clause C1. Replace the template line with: the escape device supplied shall be demonstrated to conform with the current published edition of EN 179 by [document type], issued by [named holder], covering [designation and variant], and provided to the Buyer before [programme milestone].

Annotation — the question the buyer is really asking. Not "is EN 179 enough" but "what am I going to show someone who asks where this lock's evidence is".

Turn 2 — The door decides, not the product

Procurement: We are ordering in bulk across three buildings. Only some of those doors are on escape routes. Does every lock need EN 179 evidence attached, or is this a special subset?

Technical: It is a subset, defined by the door schedule rather than by the product. EN 179 is a standard for emergency escape devices operated by a lever handle. That is a different object from the electronic locking function of a battery-driven lock, and from the horizontally actuated panic bar, which is the subject of EN 1125.

Procurement: So if a door has a panic bar and we fit the smart lock as the locking device on the same leaf, which standard governs the bar?

Technical: The bar, and the standard that covers it. The smart lock on the same leaf does not inherit the escape device's standard, and the escape device's standard does not cover the lock. Whether a door needs one, both or neither depends on the door schedule, the escape strategy and the local approving route. And on a fire door you have a third question, which is an assembly question: fire-resistance is tested as an assembly, with the hardware fitted.

CONFIRM-WITH-LOCAL-BUILDING-CONTROL-BODY — which openings in each building are classified as escape doors, which escape device type each requires, and which authority records the classification. This is a per-building and per-door-schedule question.

Evidence to demand. The door schedule from the client or the consultant, with each opening marked as escape or not and the escape device type required on each. The smart lock door measurement guide and the survey guidance in the Smart Lock Retrofit Site Survey turn that schedule into the door population you will order against.

Annotation — clause C2. Partition the requirement by opening type: "For openings classified as escape doors with a lever-operated escape device, clauses C3 to C9 apply. For openings with a horizontally actuated panic bar, the requirement is specified separately and references the standard for that device type. For all other openings, no escape-device requirement applies to this contract."

The boundary between the two device types is examined in EN 179 Versus EN 1125: Which One Applies to Your Smart Lock Door, and the scope boundary of the standard itself in EN 179 for Smart Locks: Scope, Tests and What the Standard Never Proves.

Turn 3 — The four documents a supplier can hand you

Procurement: What can a supplier actually send me?

Technical: Four things, routinely confused with each other inside factories and across the industry. A test report says somebody tested a sample. A certificate says a body attests conformity, with a scope and a validity. A declaration of conformity is the manufacturer's or importer's own legal claim about the product. Marking is the symbol printed on the product or its label. When a summary says the product has CE and nothing else, any of the four might have been meant. They sit at different rungs of trust: a marking says nothing about scope, a declaration inherits the strength of the party signing it, and only a certificate puts a third party behind a defined scope.

DocumentWhat it actually saysWhat to check before relying on itTypical failure
Test reportA sample of a described product was tested against named clausesNumber, date, who tested, the sample description, which clauses, and whether the sample matches your variantA report for another model family, offered as reassurance
CertificateA named body attests that a defined scope of product conforms to a defined standardIssuing body, number, scope wording, standards listed, issue date, validity or surveillanceA number with no scope, so nothing can be checked
Declaration of conformityThe manufacturer or importer makes its own legal claimWho signed it, in what capacity, what it covers, what evidence it rests on, whether it matches the shipped variantSigned by a party with no relationship to the product, or unsigned
MarkingThe manufacturer declares the product is placed on the market under an applicable regimeWhich regime, whether it appears on the product or only in a document, and what the supporting declaration saysA marking shown in a brochure graphic, not on the product

Procurement: So when the clause says "evidence of EN 179 conformity", which one do I write?

Technical: The one you are prepared to defend, and you name it. If your programme is going to a consultant or an approving authority who needs an attributable document, you name a certificate or, where the route is a manufacturer's own declaration, a signed declaration that names the certificate or report it rests on. You never write "evidence", because "evidence" is the word a buyer uses when they have not decided.

Evidence to demand. The full document, not the summary: the certificate with its scope page, or the report with its sample description and results. The documents worth asking for are catalogued in What Certifications Should I Request From a Smart Lock Supplier, and one is read page by page in Reading a EN 179 Test Report Page by Page: a Smart Lock Buyer Walkthrough.

Annotation — clause C3. Name the document type in the clause, not in an attachment. "A third-party certificate showing conformity with the current published edition of EN 179, with the scope page attached" is a clause. "Evidence of EN 179 conformity is to be provided" is a wish.

Turn 4 — The edition problem

Procurement: The supplier quoted the standard with a year attached to it. Which edition do I write in the clause?

Technical: You have three options and each one costs you something. Write a specific edition and you freeze the requirement, taking on the risk that the market moves to a newer edition while the order is in production. Write no edition and you accept whatever the supplier's file happens to cite, which means two quotations cannot be compared on the same basis. Write the current published edition and you make the supplier responsible for tracking it, which is the option most programmes should take.

Procurement: And if a certificate cites an older edition than the one now published?

Technical: Name it as a moving reference and pin the delivered evidence: "conformity with the current published edition of EN 179, including any amendment in force at the date the evidence is issued, the edition and amendment cited to be stated on the document supplied". Amendments are issued separately from the main edition, which is why a document saying "EN 179" plus one year can still be ambiguous, so record both. Then add a clause binding what is delivered to what was evidenced, so that if the edition changes between quotation and production the supplier tells you and you decide whether the new edition must be evidenced before shipment.

CONFIRM-WITH-LOCAL-CERTIFICATION-BODY — whether a certificate issued against one edition remains valid when a later edition or amendment is published, and what your national market's implementation guidance says at the date of your order. This is a question for the body that issued the document.

Annotation — clause C4. Edition reference plus a change-notification obligation.

Annotation — clause C5. "The product supplied shall conform to the edition and amendment cited in the evidence provided. The Supplier shall notify the Buyer in writing before shipment if the edition or amendment cited is superseded, and shall state whether the evidence remains valid."

Turn 5 — Asking about the escape function without inventing

Procurement: This is the part I have always got wrong. I want the clause to describe how the door opens in an emergency, but I do not want to write a technical requirement I cannot defend.

Technical: Then do not write the requirement. Ask the supplier to state it and to point at the evidence. The functional expectation everyone carries for a lever-operated escape device is release of the door in a single operation, without a key and without special knowledge or effort, and the published standard text sets out how that is demonstrated — confirm the precise wording against the current edition rather than a summary. Write the question instead, and make the answer carry a reference to a clause and a test in the report.

Procurement: So what exactly should the clause ask for?

Technical: It asks for three things. A description in the supplier's own words of how the door is released in an emergency, including whether the escape function depends on power. A pointer to the clause of the standard and the test in the report that demonstrates it. And the test conditions as recorded in that report, including the endurance cycle count and how the samples were conditioned. Read those from the report rather than writing them into the clause yourself, because a figure taken from a summary may belong to a different device type, a different edition or a different sample configuration.

Procurement: What about the batteries dying?

Technical: That is a real question and it belongs in the clause. Ask what the escape function does when the power source is depleted or removed, and whether the escape operation is independent of the electronics. Do not accept an answer that says "the device has a low-battery alarm" — an alarm is not a release.

Evidence to demand. A functional description, the referenced clause and test, the endurance conditions as recorded in the report, and a written statement on the escape function when power is removed. The class and grade numbering on escape device documents is decoded in Decoding EN 179 Class and Grade Numbers for Door Hardware.

Annotation — clause C6. "The Supplier shall state in writing how the escape device permits release of the door in an emergency, whether that operation requires a key, and whether it is independent of the supply of power, and shall identify the clause of EN 179 and the test in the report supplied that demonstrates this."

Annotation — clause C7. "The Supplier shall state the behaviour of the escape function when the power source is depleted or disconnected, and whether the escape operation depends on the electronics."

Turn 6 — Binding the clause to the SKU and the factory

Procurement: The evidence always seems to be for a product rather than for my product. How close does the link have to be?

Technical: As close as your variant and your production site. A certificate that covers a model family is evidence about the family. It becomes evidence about your order only when you can trace the sample, the type entry and the production site back to the thing you are buying. The gap between "the type was tested" and "this unit is that type" is where disputes live.

Procurement: So I ask what the certificate covers.

Technical: Ask for the type entry exactly as it reads on the document, the product designation you have quoted, the finish and faceplate options you have chosen, and the production site the goods will come from. If the goods come from a second factory, ask for evidence covering that factory too, or a written statement of what the certificate does not extend to. And after the sample passed, ask what keeps it true: a stated control on changes to the type, a surveillance arrangement, an inspection regime, or an internal control the supplier can describe and evidence.

Evidence to demand. The certificate scope and type entry, cross-checked against your own quoted designation; a written statement on production sites covered; and the production-control arrangement that keeps the evidence valid between the sample and the container. The factory-side checks are in Smart Lock Factory Audit Checklist for International Buyers, and who carries that cost in an original-equipment programme is examined in Who Pays for EN 179 Evidence in a Smart Lock OEM Programme.

Annotation — clause C8. Object of the evidence. "The evidence supplied shall cover the product designation, finish, faceplate and variant as quoted, and shall state the production site covered."

Annotation — clause C9. Production control. "The Supplier shall state the production-control and type-change arrangement that maintains the conformity of the delivered product with the evidence supplied, and shall notify the Buyer of any change to the type or production site."

Turn 7 — Grading the answers that come back

Procurement: I now have the right questions. But suppliers reply in paragraphs.

Technical: Grade the answer, not the tone. A long reply that names the document type, the edition, the type entry, the production site and the change-notification route is a strong answer. A reply that says the product "meets all applicable international standards" is not a weak answer to your question; it is not an answer at all, and it should be returned the day it arrives.

Signal in the replyReadingAction
Document type named and the document attachedAnswerableGrade against the evidence ladder
A standard listed with no document attachedNot yet an answerRequest the document, naming the type
A scope page listing a different product familyWrong objectReject and re-ask with the designation quoted
An edition cited without the amendmentAmbiguousAsk for both
A marketing page and a test report offered for one clauseTwo claims at different rungsAsk which one the supplier relies on here
An undertaking to provide the certificate after the orderNot in existence at awardMake the timing binding before quotations are compared

Procurement: Is there a way to make this objective rather than a judgement call?

Technical: Set the rung you are buying at before you issue the request for quotation, and write it in. If the programme is a tender with an approving authority behind it, you are likely buying at the rung where a third-party document with a scope covers your exact variant; if it is a smaller direct purchase, a test report on a described sample plus a signed declaration may be the realistic rung. What you must not do is issue a request for quotation that is silent on the rung and then accept whatever arrives.

Annotation — clause C10. Response format. "Responses shall identify, for each clause, the document type relied upon, its holder, number and date, the product designation and production site covered, and shall attach the document. A response that does not attach a document is not a response to that clause."

Turn 8 — The conformity route, the marking and the declaration

Procurement: One supplier sent a document saying the product is placed on the market under a directive and that the company declares conformity. Another said the product is marked. Neither mentions EN 179. Does that close the clause?

Technical: It closes nothing. A marking is the manufacturer's declaration that the product is placed on the market under an applicable regime. A declaration of conformity is the manufacturer's own legal claim. Neither tells you what the escape device was tested against. Two routes to market are running in parallel with your clause.

Procurement: Is the EN 179 route a certification route or a declaration route?

Technical: That depends on the regime your market applies to the product and on the standard's own conformity assessment provisions, and it is the sort of question that gets answered badly in a hurry. For door hardware sold as a construction product, the construction products route drives a Declaration of Performance rather than only a declaration of conformity, and that is where the mechanically operated and electromechanically operated lock families sit. Whether the escape device on your door falls inside any harmonised or cited route for the market you are supplying, and what third-party involvement that route requires, is a per-product and per-market question.

CONFIRM-WITH-LOCAL-LEGAL-ADVISER — which conformity route applies to the escape device in each market you are supplying, whether a Declaration of Performance is required in addition to a declaration of conformity, and which party in your supply chain carries the legal obligation to hold and to produce it. Check the published scope and the harmonised list in force for each market at the date of your order.

CONFIRM-WITH-LOCAL-REGULATORY-CONSULTANT — whether the marking on the product and the evidence supplied under clauses C1 to C9 are consistent, and whether the mark needed differs from the mark already on the product for each destination market.

Procurement: So the escape device clause and the marking clause are separate clauses?

Technical: They are separate clauses that share a single verification step. Your evidence schedule lists both, and the review checks that the two do not contradict each other — for example, a marking on the label that names a regime whose route the escape device evidence does not support. The clause language for the marking side is written on the same pattern as this one.

Annotation — clause C11. Keep the routes apart on paper. "Conformity evidence under clauses C1 to C9 relates solely to the escape device requirement. Any marking, declaration or market-access document provided under this request for quotation is supplied in addition and does not substitute for that evidence, and the Supplier shall confirm the two are consistent."

Turn 9 — Where the EN 179 clause has to stop

Procurement: Our integrator asked whether the same lock also satisfies the radio requirement, the ingress rating and the fire rating, so we can put it on all the doors.

Technical: That is four standards asked to answer one another's questions, and it is the most expensive drafting error in a request for quotation. The escape device standard answers the escape device question, a radio standard answers the radio question, an ingress or impact rating answers the environment question, and a fire rating answers the assembly question. Writing them into one clause does not make the product better covered; it makes the clause unanswerable, and it hands the supplier a reason to answer with the weakest of the four.

Requirement a buyer may wantThe standard or regime that actually answers itWhat the EN 179 clause must not be used for
Emergency escape by lever-operated deviceEN 179The electronic locking function of the lock
Emergency escape by panic barEN 1125The lever-operated device requirement
Electromechanically operated lock and striking plateEN 14846Escape release
Radio and electromagnetic compatibilityThe radio and electromagnetic regimes for the destination marketEscape release or mechanical durability
Fire and smoke door assembly performanceThe fire-resistance test route for assembliesStand-alone hardware performance

Procurement: So the EN 179 clause should have an explicit exclusion?

Technical: It should have a boundary, and the boundary does the work. A clause that says what this requirement covers and what it does not cover prevents it being borrowed for a claim it cannot support, in either direction — in your tender pack and in the supplier's own marketing, which will quote your request for quotation back to you.

CONFIRM-WITH-LOCAL-FIRE-ENGINEER — where an electronic lock is proposed on a fire or smoke door, the assembly requirements and the maintenance regime that apply to that door, and which components of the assembly are tested with the door. Hardware performance on a fire door is an assembly question, and the answer is local to the building.

Annotation — clause C12. Boundary clause. "The escape device requirement in this request for quotation applies only to the escape device on the openings identified in the door schedule. It is not evidence of conformity with any other standard, and no document supplied under clauses C1 to C9 shall be relied upon as evidence for radio, electromagnetic compatibility, ingress or impact protection, fire or smoke door assembly performance, mechanical lock durability, cylinder performance or handle furniture."

The escape and panic family has its own template language and its own document list: Egress and Panic Hardware: Template Language for a Specification and Egress and Panic Hardware: Documents a Specifier Should Demand. The parallel clause sets for the sibling standards are in Writing EN 1125 Into a Smart Lock RFQ: Clause Language that Gets Real Answers and Writing EN 14846 Into a Smart Lock RFQ: Clause Language that Gets Real Answers.

Turn 10 — Rewriting the weak clauses

Technical: Read the middle column first: it is the failure each weak clause invites. Only then look at the right-hand column.

Weak clauseWhat it fails to bindClause as it should read
Lock shall comply with EN 179Document type, object, holder, dateThe escape device shall be shown to conform with the current published edition of EN 179 by a certificate from [body] whose scope covers [designation and variant], provided before [milestone]
CE certificate to be providedWhether EN 179 is inside the scope of that markThe Supplier shall provide the marking and supporting declaration in force for each destination market, separately from the escape device evidence
Factory to be certified against EN 179Who attests, for which scopeThe certificate holder shall be named, with number and scope page attached
Latest edition of EN 179 shall applyWhat happens when it changes mid-orderThe edition and amendment cited shall be stated, and any superseding edition notified before shipment
Escape function shall be manual and fail-safeWhether anyone has checked itThe Supplier shall state how the device releases the door and identify the clause and test demonstrating it

Procurement: Several of these weak clauses are ones I have sent.

Technical: Most of them are ones everybody has sent. That is why the request for quotation needs to be a controlled document rather than a set of inherited table rows, and why the template behind it is worth reviewing before the next issue rather than after. The Smart Lock Supplier Due Diligence Checklist and the Hotel Smart Lock RFQ Guide are the documents to hand to whoever maintains the template.

Annotation — clause C13. Evidence schedule and timing. The schedule is a table with one row per clause: clause reference, document type required, object covered, holder, date, and the milestone before which it is due. A clause with no row in the schedule is a clause nobody is working on.

Turn 11 — Sending the clause sheet

Procurement: How do I introduce this without sounding like I distrust the supplier?

Technical: Do not frame it as distrust. Frame it as the basis on which quotations will be compared. Every supplier in the pack will be asked the same clauses in the same form and will be asked for the same document types, so the comparison is fair and the programme can move. Say that the request for quotation is being reissued this cycle with a defined evidence schedule, that it applies to all respondents equally, and that the evidence requested is what the consultant and the approving authority will read.

Procurement: And if a supplier says the clause is unusual?

Technical: Ask them to state the clause in question and what they would propose instead, in the same structure: requirement, document, object, holder, timing, consequence. If their answer is that the evidence does not exist in a form that meets the clause, that is a finding you want before you award.

Procurement: What if they offer the evidence later, after the order?

Technical: Then you have a decision to make consciously. Either the evidence is a condition of award, in which case it is in the clause and the comparison is made on the documents in hand, or it is a condition of shipment, in which case it is a different clause with a different consequence, and it should say what happens if it is not produced. Writing "evidence to follow" without a date and a consequence is how a programme discovers, at goods-in, that it bought a claim rather than a document.

Annotation — clause C14. "Failure to provide the evidence required by clauses C1 to C9 by the date stated shall entitle the Buyer to reject the quotation, to remove the relevant product from the technical comparison, or to withhold the order, at the Buyer's option."

Annotation — clause C15. "Where the Supplier proposes a change to the product designation, the type entry, the production site or the certification route after the issue of this request for quotation, the evidence schedule shall be reissued and re-satisfied before that change is accepted."

Turn 12 — When the evidence comes back thin

Procurement: This is where I always land. I get a file, it looks substantial, and it does not cover the thing I ordered. How do I see that before I pay for the freight?

Technical: You use a ladder, and you know which rung you are standing on. The rungs run from a marketing image at the bottom to production-control evidence at the top. The programme must know which rung it is buying at, because the recurring failure is buying near the bottom and finding out at installation that nothing above it was ever going to exist. For en 179 smart lock rfq clause, the position on this ladder is what the purchase decision turns on.

stateDiagram-v2
    [*] --> MarketingImage
    MarketingImage --> SelfDeclaredDoC
    SelfDeclaredDoC --> SampleReport
    SampleReport --> ThirdPartyCertificate
    ThirdPartyCertificate --> SkuCoveredCertificate
    SkuCoveredCertificate --> ProductionControl
    ProductionControl --> [*]
    note right of SampleReport
        Evidence about a sample of a described product
    end note
    note right of SkuCoveredCertificate
        The scope covers the variant actually ordered
    end note

Procurement: So a signed declaration is low on the ladder?

Technical: It is rung two, and it is not worthless. It is the manufacturer's own legal claim, which carries weight because the manufacturer carries the legal exposure. What it does not carry is the third-party attribution a consultant or an approving authority may want, and it tells you nothing about the scope, the edition or the variant. Never accept a rung without naming it.

Procurement: And if I receive a certificate whose scope covers the right family but not my exact variant?

Technical: Then you are at rung four, looking at rung five. That is a legitimate place to be for a programme with a sensible risk position, provided the clause says so and the gap is recorded. It is not a legitimate place to be if your approving authority expects the scope to cover the ordered variant, and that is a question to put to the consultant before the award. The ways evidence disappoints buyers are set out in Three Ways EN 179 Evidence Disappoints Smart Lock Buyers.

Annotation — the rung statement. Add one line to the request for quotation: "The Buyer is purchasing at the evidence rung stated in the evidence schedule. Responses are evaluated at that rung, and the Buyer may not substitute a lower rung for the rung stated." Naming the rung converts an argument about how much evidence is enough into a decision you made in advance.

The annotated clause sheet

Collected, the clauses below are what a request for quotation would carry. They are written to be lifted, not admired, and the bracketed fields are the ones only the programme can fill in.

RefClause as it should readDocument that must existBound to
C1The escape device shall be shown to conform with the current published edition of EN 179 by [document type], issued by [holder], covering [designation and variant], provided before [milestone]Certificate or signed declarationSupplier
C2The requirement applies only to openings classified as escape doors with a lever-operated device, listed in the door scheduleDoor schedule from the clientBuyer and consultant
C3Evidence shall be supplied as a full document with its scopeFull document with scope pageSupplier
C4Conformity is to the edition and amendment cited, with the current edition including any amendment in force at the date of issueEdition statement on the documentSupplier
C5The Supplier shall notify the Buyer before shipment if the cited edition or amendment is superseded, and state whether the evidence remains validSupplier notificationSupplier
C6The Supplier shall state how the device releases the door in an emergency, whether a key is required, and identify the clause and test demonstrating itReport with referenced clause and testSupplier
C7The Supplier shall state the behaviour of the escape function when power is depleted or disconnectedWritten statement, plus test evidence if claimedSupplier
C8Evidence shall cover the designation, finish, faceplate and variant as quoted, and state the production siteScope and type entrySupplier
C9The Supplier shall state the production-control and type-change arrangement and notify any change to the type or siteDescription of the arrangementSupplier
C10Responses shall identify document type, holder, number, date, designation and production site, and attach the documentComplete response per clauseEach respondent
C11Escape device evidence and any market-access marking or declaration are separate; the Supplier shall confirm they are consistentBoth sets, cross-checkedSupplier
C12The requirement does not evidence conformity with any other standard, and may not be relied upon as evidence for radio, ingress or impact, fire assembly, lock durability, cylinder or handle furnitureBoundary statementBuyer
C13The evidence schedule lists one row per clause with document type, object, holder, date and due milestoneThe schedule itselfBuyer
C14Failure to provide the required evidence by the stated date entitles the Buyer to reject the quotation, remove the product from comparison, or withhold the orderConsequence clauseBuyer
C15Any change to designation, type entry, production site or certification route after issue requires reissue and re-satisfaction of the scheduleChange notificationSupplier

Two fields deserve attention. The milestone in C1 and C13 decides whether you are comparing documents or comparing promises. The consequence in C14 is what makes the milestone real; a milestone without a consequence is a date nobody has to meet.

Where this dialogue stops

The transcript cannot tell you whether your doors need escape devices, because that is a question about the door schedule, the escape strategy of each building and the local approving route, and those answers do not travel between projects. It cannot tell you which lock to specify, or whether a given market treats your product under a certification route or a declaration route, and it deliberately takes no position on that.

It also cannot tell you how much evidence is enough. That is a programme risk decision, and the value of the ladder is that it lets you make the decision explicitly and in writing, instead of discovering the answer by accepting whatever arrives first.

What it does give you is a clause set that cannot be answered with a brochure, a distinction between the four document types that get confused in every enquiry, and a request for quotation that records which rung of evidence the programme is buying at. The tender-pack version of the evidence list is in EN 179 in a Smart Lock Tender Pack: the Evidence Checklist, and the scope limits of the standard are set out in EN 179 for Smart Locks: Scope, Tests and What the Standard Never Proves.

Six moves before the request for quotation goes

  1. Get the door schedule and classify the openings. Escape or not, and which escape device type each escape opening carries.
  2. Partition the requirement before you write it. One clause set for lever-operated escape devices, a separate reference for panic bar devices, none for the rest.
  3. Decide the evidence rung and write it into the schedule, before quotations arrive.
  4. Write the object fields. Model designation, variant, finish, production site, filled in from your own quotation lines.
  5. Set the milestone and the consequence together. A deadline without a consequence is not a deadline.
  6. Check the boundary clause covers the neighbours. Radio, environment, fire assembly and mechanical lock performance are separate questions.

The questions procurement will be asked next

"The supplier says the product already has CE. Why are you asking for more?" Because a marking is a claim about a market-access regime and does not tell you which clauses of which standard were tested on which sample. The two documents answer different questions, and clause C11 keeps them apart.

"Can we just ask for the certificate number and check it ourselves?" You can, and you should, but the number alone carries no scope. The scope page tells you what is covered; the number tells you who to ask for it. Ask for the document.

For the sourcing-side preparation around these moves, the Smart Lock Supplier Due Diligence Checklist and the Hotel Smart Lock RFQ Guide are the practical documents to hand to a supplier. The order samples page describes the product-side review, the certifications page the conformity documentation route, and request a quote the route where a scoped enquiry saves a round of correspondence.

Su carrito
Su experiencia en este sitio mejorará al permitir cookies Política de cookies
Chat on WhatsApp