Bid Leveling in Retrofit Projects
A requirement written once and reused well saves more time than a clever quotation, so bid leveling retrofit projects is given as a working resource. This is the working diary of a levelling session I ran on a retrofit tender, kept in the order the days went rather than in the order a method would present them. The project was a building being converted; the doors were already in place, made to a local practice decades earlier; and the tender was for electronic locks to go onto them. Four returns came back, and not one of them was for the doors in the building.
That sentence carries most of the retrofit problem, so it is worth being precise about it before going any further. A bidder answering a lock tender prices a lock against a door it believes it is being asked about. On a new-build job that door exists on paper, drawn to a dimension, and both sides of the tender can point at it. On a retrofit job the door is a leaf of unstated thickness with a lock pocket cut by somebody who has since left, a frame that may be steel and may be timber, and an escape route that the original designer arranged around a mechanical lock nobody is going to see again. A bidder cannot price that from a catalogue, so the bidder prices a stand-in door instead, and the stand-in door is written into the quotation as though it were the specification.
Levelling a retrofit tender is therefore mostly an exercise in converting an existing door population into a statement a bidder can price against, and then refusing to average away the doors that fit no single product. Everything in this diary follows from that. I kept the notes the way I kept them: the survey, the basis, the return-by-return reading, the questions that could only be answered on site, and the recommendation that finally named which door population each part of the award was actually about.
Most of what follows applies to bid leveling retrofit projects specifically, so it is worth saying what the diary is not. No client, building or supplier is named, and the project is an illustrative composite of the kind of work that arrives on this desk. There are no prices, order quantities, production lead times or warranty periods in it, because commercial terms are quoted to a buyer in writing rather than published. Any statement about what a particular model does is a per-supplier fact to be confirmed on the dated product page for the specific SKU. Where a question belongs to a public authority, it is written as the question to ask and the evidence to demand, because the authority that decides differs by market and by building. The vocabulary is the specifier's own, and if a term is unfamiliar the Smart Lock Glossary: Bid Leveling Definition for B2b Buyers entry sets it out.
Direct answer. In brief, this article covers bid leveling retrofit projects from bid leveling retrofit projects to bid-leveling. It states what to confirm about bid leveling retrofit projects on the dated product page where a figure is involved. A bid leveling retrofit projects is a resource for whoever writes the requirement. bid leveling retrofit projects turns a request for bid leveling retrofit projects into something a supplier can price.
Monday: the survey that has to happen before any comparison
The survey was done on the third floor first, because that was where the corridor of twenty-one doors sat and where the door types were least consistent. The building had been through three eras of alteration. The corridor doors were solid timber leaves of a thickness nobody in the office had written down. The stairwell door was a steel assembly with a device on it that we had to work around, not remove. Two storage doors were hollow-core and light enough to be carried by one person. A plant room door was a fire door that nobody was authorised to cut. What the specification covers is in the smart door locks.
The surveyor measured each opening and wrote the value against the door number. The table below is the working form, trimmed to the rows that decided something on this job.
| As-built measurement | What it decides | Evidence kept with the survey |
|---|---|---|
| Leaf thickness at the lock, hinge and strike positions | Whether an existing mortise pocket can be reused and which case and spindle lengths can be offered | Measured value per opening, against the door number |
| Backset from the leaf edge to the centre of the spindle | The distance the installer works to, and the one most often left out | Measured value, not a range inferred from a drawing |
| Bore diameter and bolt-to-bore distance | Whether the supplied case fits the hole that is already in the door | Both values recorded separately |
| Existing lock case pocket size and shape | Whether the job is a replacement, a conversion or a first fit | Photograph with the old case still in place |
| Leading-edge and head gaps, and the reveal | Whether the latch and deadbolt engage as supplied | Measured gap and the reveal in the same line |
| Frame construction and strike-box depth | Whether the strike can be replaced and whether the frame needs work | Frame detail and the strike-box measurement |
| Hinge-side clearance with the door open against the frame | Whether the handle or lever returns foul the frame | Photograph with the door fully open |
| Cut-outs already in the leaf | Whether the new body fouls a letterbox, a viewer or a closer arm | Photograph showing the relationship to the cut-out |
The Smart Lock Retrofit Site Survey is the instrument this desk works from, and the individual measurements behind the table are set out in the Smart Lock Backset Measurement, Smart Lock Door Thickness Measurement, Smart Lock Lock Case Measurement and Smart Lock Strike Plate Measurement references, with the wider method in the Smart Lock Door Measurement Guide.
The lesson from the Monday is the one I have written into the template since. In retrofit the survey is not a formality that precedes ordering; it is the specification. Every value on that sheet is the dimension the installer needs, stated in the format the supplier quotes in, and if the value is not in the tender pack the bidder will supply an assumption of their own and price it. If the answer has to survive a supplier meeting, Bid Leveling for a Hotel Project is the next one to read.
Monday afternoon: writing the basis before the numbers
The returns had already arrived, which was a mistake I would not repeat. The remedy was to fix the basis before comparing anything rather than after, and to date it. The date matters because a return can be answered against the basis only if the version of the basis it was answered against is identifiable.
The basis for this job was not the usual list of commercial lines with a technical section attached. It opened with the door, because the door was the object every quotation was about. Eight lines carried the whole comparison.
| Line on the basis sheet | What it fixed in a retrofit tender |
|---|---|
| Door population, as measured, by opening | The object each quotation is actually a price for |
| Configuration against each door population | Which case, faceplate, handing and finish apply where |
| Scope of supply per door population | What the number includes for that group of doors |
| Preparation, cutting and making good | Who modifies the leaf, and who carries the repair |
| Handover boundary on an existing door | Where the supplier's responsibility stops |
| Delivery term with a named place | What the cross-border leg actually buys |
| Documentation standard per variant | Which document type is acceptable for the product offered |
| Locking arrangement and evidence per egress door | What the escape route does, and who approved it |
The interesting part of that table is what is absent. There is no single product line, because the building does not have a single product. There are six door populations across the twenty-one openings, and the corridor alone contains leaves whose measured thickness differs enough that a case which suits the thinnest of them may not reach the thickest. The Smart Lock Retrofit Compatibility Guide covers the compatibility question in more depth; what the basis sheet needed was the compatibility question answered per population.
A comparison started before the basis is dated is a preference with arithmetic laid over it. Once a headline figure is in the room, every later argument defends that figure instead of testing the basis it is supposed to rest on.
Tuesday: reading four returns against one building
Four returns: three from factories in other markets and one from a local installer who subcontracted the supply. Read in sequence, the returns had a pattern. Each of them was internally coherent and each of them was answering a slightly different building.
| What the bidder assumed | How the assumption appears in the return | The question that closes it |
|---|---|---|
| One door type across the whole count | A single product line and a single unit price for every opening | Which openings does this price cover, and which door population is it priced for |
| A standard leaf thickness | No thickness stated anywhere in the response | State the leaf thicknesses assumed, in millimetres, at the lock position |
| A solid leaf that can be modified | No mention of preparation or making good | Does the price include modifying an existing pocket, and does it assume a solid core |
| A frame that takes the supplied strike | Faceplate and strike named as a set, with no frame depth | State the faceplate and strike dimensions and the frame depth they assume |
| An escape route untouched by the work | No egress line in the return | What is the locking arrangement on the escape door, and which record names it |
| A finish that will match the doors | A finish name and nothing else | State the finish as a colour reference, and whether supply is a batch reference |
The lesson from Tuesday is about the difference between two kinds of difference. In bid leveling retrofit projects most of the difference on the page is the second kind. A difference in the product is real and has to stay visible on the page. A difference in the assumption about the building is not a difference at all; it is a gap, and the only honest way to close it is to ask the question and wait for a sourced answer. Three of the four returns were cheaper or dearer than the fourth partly because of what they had assumed about doors that were not there.
That distinction matters commercially, because a gap answered by an assumption is a gap that will surface during installation, when the party holding the gap has no authority over the door.
Tuesday afternoon: the conditions that decide whether a lock
A condition table is a different thing from a product table. The product table asks what is offered; the condition table asks whether the offered thing can physically be fitted to what is already in the building, and it is the second table that decides the retrofit job.
| As-built condition | What it changes | Why it is invisible in a return |
|---|---|---|
| Existing mortise pocket present and reusable | The case has to match a pocket it did not cut | The bidder assumed a new preparation |
| Hollow-core leaf | Fixings, screw length and the case itself may not suit the leaf | Nothing on a datasheet describes a hollow leaf |
| Steel or composite leaf | Whether the leaf can be cut at all, and by whom | Cutting a steel leaf is a trade decision, not a product one |
| Multipoint locking on the entrance door | Several locking points operated by one gear must be replaced by one gear or not replaced at all | The gear count is not a headline specification |
| Existing exit device or closer retained | The backset, the faceplate and the swing direction are all constrained | The return describes a new lock, not a room with a lock in it |
| Leaf sag or movement over its service life | Gaps and the reveal are not the values a new leaf would give | The doors have moved since they were hung |
| Existing key system in the building | Whether the new locks join a hierarchy or start a second one | A lock is priced per unit; a key system is priced per building |
The multipoint row cost the most argument. An entrance door that locks at several points through one gear is not replaced by a product with one latch; the gear count and the locking arrangement have to match what the door does now, or the door's behaviour on a panic is changed without anyone having decided to change it. A retrofit tender that reduces a multipoint door to a standard mortise case has quietly made a security decision that was never on the agenda.
The last row of that table is the one that got the building's operations manager into the room. The building already had a master key system with levels below it, and the operation had doors deliberately outside it. A lock that does not join that hierarchy creates a second system, and a second system is a permanent running cost rather than a one-off installation cost.
CONFIRM-PER-SUPPLIER — the locking arrangement, case type, faceplate dimensions and door-fit envelope for any model offered against a measured door population are per-supplier, per-variant facts. Ask for the dimensioned drawing or the installation sheet for the exact SKU rather than inferring them from a family brochure.
Wednesday: the escape route nobody drew for this building
The escape doors were the part of this tender I had least freedom over, because the locking arrangement on them had been decided by someone else, in another decade, and approved by an authority that was not in the room.
What I could do was write the question in a form that lets the authority answer it. Whether the locking arrangement on each escape door is the one the authority approved, whether that approval is written down and dated, and whether the electronic lock proposed for that door leaves the escape route operating without special knowledge, are all questions for the party that owns the decision rather than for the tender panel. The door set includes the egress route and the locking arrangement as one thing, and a lock that changes how the door behaves on a panic changes the assembly that was approved.
Three authorities were relevant and they are not interchangeable. The building control function decides what the altered door assembly must satisfy. The fire authority decides where a fire-rated door may be modified at all. The access consultant decides whether the operable part, its force and its motion still work on the installed door, which is a question about the door in the building and not about the sample on the desk.
CONFIRM-WITH-LOCAL-BUILDING-CONTROL — whether the altered door assembly and its locking arrangement require notification or approval in this jurisdiction, and what record the authority expects to receive with the hardware package.
CONFIRM-WITH-FIRE-AUTHORITY — whether cutting or re-hanging a fire-rated door, or changing its locking arrangement, requires the fire authority's agreement, and in what form that agreement is given and recorded.
CONFIRM-WITH-ACCESS-CONSULTANT — whether the operable part, the force and the motion of the proposed lock have been assessed on the installed door and on the existing frame, rather than on the sample.
The line supervision and egress interface vocabulary belongs in this section rather than in the hardware section, because it describes how the building learns that the door has been opened and how it is told that an exit device has been operated. Whether the proposed lock is wired for that at all, or reports over a radio path that nobody has specified, changes the door's behaviour in a way the client will want to know about before the award rather than after the first fire drill.
Wednesday afternoon: the price lines that only exist
Bid levelling normally works by putting two quotations onto one basis so the same thing can be compared. In retrofit the work is the other way round: there are lines in the quotation that have no equivalent in a new-build tender, and if the basis does not name them, the lowest number wins by being the least complete.
| Retrofit-only line | What it is | Who normally carries it |
|---|---|---|
| Survey and scheduling of occupied openings | Measuring and booking doors in a building that is still in use | The supplier or a specialist subcontractor |
| Protection and working around other trades | Dust, noise and clearances in a live building | The installer |
| Making good after cutting | Filling, priming and finishing where a pocket was opened | Whoever holds the preparation scope |
| Removal and disposal of the old hardware | Taking out the existing lock, cylinder and strike | The installer, or the building's own maintenance |
| Key system transition | Extending, retiring or running in parallel an existing hierarchy | The client, with the installer |
| Out-of-hours or phased working | Doors that cannot be closed during working hours | The installer |
| Spares matched to the remaining old type | Keeping the doors not yet converted working | The client, under a stated period |
| Abortive visit | A door that turns out not to match the survey on the day | Whichever party carried the survey |
Two of those lines decide whether a retrofit tender is honest at all. The first is the survey: if the supplier carried it and the survey was wrong, that cost is the supplier's, and if the client carried it and it was wrong, the client pays to revisit twenty-one doors. Stating which party carried the survey is a levelling instruction, not a contract nicety, because it moves a visible cost between two bids.
The second is making good. A quotation that excludes preparation will look cheaper than one that includes it and will produce a worse building, because the difference between a neatly cut pocket and a filled one is visible to everybody and is not visible in a spreadsheet.
CONFIRM-WITH-LOCAL-LEGAL — whether an unequal basis between bidders has consequences for the tender procedure, and what the client's rules say about a return that does not answer the basis sheet, depend on the contract and the governing law. Take the point with counsel before the basis is issued. Nothing in this diary is legal advice.
Thursday: evidence at the level of the variant
The evidence conversation on this job went somewhere I did not expect. It was not about whether a certificate existed; it was about whether the variant a bidder was offering reached the thickest leaf in the corridor and whether the evidence named that variant.
A supplier's own product record is per-model and structured in fields: the door fit, the case type, the panel, the power source, the finish. The first-party catalogue behind this business runs to 79 published models, and the pattern holds across them — a door-thickness envelope belongs to one model and is not transferable to another, and for a large share of the range that field is simply absent, which means the question has to be asked rather than assumed. Two bids can cite identical-sounding documentation and still be offering different envelopes.
The linkage the retrofit job demands is this one: the variant quoted must be shown to cover the measured door population it is being offered against. A certificate that names a model does not answer that. A drawing that gives a case and a faceplate does answer it, if it is compared against the survey value for the door it will be fitted to.
| Evidence item | What it settles in a retrofit tender | What it does not settle |
|---|---|---|
| Dimensioned drawing for the exact variant | Whether the case, faceplate and spindle reach the measured door | Whether the door on site is as measured |
| Installation sheet naming the door thickness range | Whether the variant covers the thickest and thinnest leaf in the group | Whether the installation will be done to it |
| Certificate or declaration naming the variant and its scope | Which evidence exists for the product being bought | Whether the product fits the door |
| Packing list against the declared scope | Whether the strike, fixings and power source travel with the lock | Whether the frame accepts the strike |
| Sample fitted to a real leaf | That the case, spindle and faceplate physically work on this door | How the door performs over its service life |
The sample row is the one that changed the project. A mock-up evidences fit, not performance, and that limit is worth stating plainly because it is often assumed otherwise. A case fitted to the thickest leaf in the corridor, with the existing strike box in place, answered in an afternoon the question that three written returns had left open. The approval was recorded and dated, which is the only thing that makes it evidence later.
CONFIRM-PER-SUPPLIER — every dimension, envelope and marking quoted against a specific model belongs to the supplier and the specific variant, and is confirmed on the dated product page for that SKU. Where a claim sits in a document rather than a page, ask for the document with its scope and its date.
Thursday afternoon: the cross-border paperwork inside
Three of the four returns came from factories in other markets, and each carried a different set of assumptions about the paperwork that follows the goods. This is where retrofit levelling stops being a door survey and becomes a question about which party's obligation the quotation is buying.
The first was the delivery term. "Delivered" is not a basis; a delivery term attached to a named place is, and in retrofit the place has an awkward property — the goods arrive at a building where the doors are already installed, which means the sequence of delivery is tied to the installer rather than to the site. The second was importer of record, which decides who holds the pre-shipment conformity obligation, and that is a determination made in the destination market on the facts of the shipment. The third was the language of the documents, which is not a translation nicety: the installation sheet is read by the person cutting the pocket, and the sheet they cannot read is the sheet that will be ignored.
The translation problem sat underneath all three. The doors in the building were made locally, to a local practice, and the local practice is the reason the leaves are the thickness they are. A bidder in another market has learned a different local norm, and that learned norm is what appears in the return as an assumption. The door schedule therefore has to be dimensional rather than descriptive — the dimension the installer needs is the value, stated in the unit the supplier quotes in — because a description of a door type carries the reader's own assumptions back into it.
| Cross-border item to normalise | What each return had assumed | The question put to every bidder |
|---|---|---|
| Delivery term and named place | Different places, different carriers, different arrival points | Which named place does this term attach to |
| Importer of record | Sometimes the bidder, sometimes the client, sometimes silent | Who is importer of record in the destination market |
| Pre-shipment conformity obligation | Usually silent | Which party carries it for this shipment |
| Language of the installation sheet and manual | Unstated, or assumed to be English | In which language must the sheet the installer reads be issued |
| Evidence holder after delivery | Left with the bidder | Which named person holds the evidence for the variant supplied |
| Change notification before production | Silent | What written notice is given before a change to the case, the reader, the finish or the packaging |
CONFIRM-WITH-CUSTOMS-BROKER — classification, valuation and the tax treatment of a shipment are determinations made on the facts of that product and that consignment, and they differ between lanes and between products. Confirm them for the specific SKU and the specific shipment rather than inferring them from a comparison.
Friday: putting the restated returns on one sheet
By Friday the four returns were restated onto the same eight-line basis, and the sheet looked less like a price comparison and more like a map of the building. Each door population had become a row, because that is what the building actually is.
| Door population on site | What the lowest return assumed | What the second return assumed | What the third return assumed | Treatment in the comparison |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Corridor leaves, thinnest group | One standard thickness | Measured thickness, quoted | Two thicknesses treated as one | Compare on measured thickness; mark the gap |
| Corridor leaves, thickest group | Same product as the thin group | Variant with a wider envelope | Variant reaching only the thinner range | Separate row; the substitution is visible |
| Solid core office doors | Reuse of the existing pocket | Replacement of the case | New preparation included | Compare preparation lines, not unit prices |
| Hollow-core storage doors | Not considered | Surface-mounted case priced | Not considered | Scope gap; a bid that ignores them is not a bid for the building |
| Steel fire door | Not considered | Not considered | Cut pocket priced, subject to permission | Compliance question precedes the price |
| Multibolt entrance door | Single latch priced | Multipoint arrangement priced | Not considered | Locking arrangement row; authority question |
| Existing key system | New locks only | Extends the hierarchy | Parallel system offered | Ongoing cost row; client decision |
The map below is the same logic as a diagram, and it is worth drawing because the sequence is not obvious: a measured dimension leads to a case length, a case length leads to a variant, and only a variant fitted to a real leaf produces an approval.
graph LR
A["Measured leaf thickness range"] --> B["Case length and spindle cover"]
B --> C["Variant that reaches the thickest leaf"]
A --> D["Faceplate and strike dimensions"]
D --> E["Strike box depth in the existing frame"]
C --> F["Sample fitted to a real leaf"]
E --> F
F --> G["Recorded approval of the mock-up"]
The lesson from Friday is that the comparison sheet for a retrofit has to be read against the door population, not against the bidders. A panel that reads it the other way round will conclude that one bid is more complete than another, when what has really happened is that one bid has noticed more of the building.
Friday afternoon: the questions only an existing building raises
The clarification round on a retrofit tender is longer than on a new-build tender, and the reason is simple: the questions are about a building, and the answers are on site.
| Question raised | Why only an existing building asks it | The answer format that closes it |
|---|---|---|
| Is the existing mortise pocket reused, converted or replaced | Only relevant where a pocket already exists | One of the three, per door population, with the pocket dimension |
| Is the leaf solid or hollow core, and what fixing does that need | A hollow leaf changes the case and the fixings | Construction stated, evidenced by a section photograph |
| May the leaf be cut, and who authorises it | Some doors are listed assemblies that cannot be opened up | Yes or no, with the instruction where the answer is no |
| What is the strike box depth in the existing frame | Decides whether the strike is replaced or adapted | Measured depth and the frame build-up |
| Who removes the old lock and cylinder, and when | A key system has to be decommissioned in sequence | Named party and the date in the programme |
| Is the existing key system retained on any door | Decides whether one system or two exists in the building | Yes or no, and the doors deliberately outside key control |
| What state is the door left in if the lock is removed for repair | The state on power loss follows the role of the door | The state stated per door, decided by the door's role |
| Who signs the door as installed, and in what form | The record has to survive handover | A name, a date and the document that holds them |
Two answers came back that changed the outcome. The first was the hollow-core leaf: the return that had quietly ignored it was not comparable on that population at all, and the panel had to either exclude it or ask it to price a different product for those doors. The second was the question about the state the door is left in if the lock is removed for repair, which is where the fail-safe and fail-secure decision surfaced. Which state a lock takes on power loss is decided by the role of the door in the building, not by the product, and the returns had all been silent about it.
CONFIRM-PER-SUPPLIER — the state a lock takes on power loss, the power source and any backup arrangement, and the interface behaviour for a door that is monitored, are per-supplier facts for the specific variant. Confirm them on the dated product page for that SKU and write them into the submittal requirement.
The recommendation, and the doors it names
The recommendation that left this session was short, and it was short because the sheet had already done the work. Four parts, in this order, because the residual risk has to be visible before the choice and not after it.
The first part was the basis: the eight lines, the date they were fixed, who fixed them, and the survey revision they refer to. The second was the restated comparison: each return against that basis, with unanswered items marked as unanswered rather than inferred from a brochure. The third was the residual: for each door population, the risk that remains after the award, and who owns it. The fourth was the recommendation, with its conditions attached.
The retrofit-specific part of the fourth part is the naming. The award was to one supplier, and it covered two product configurations on two door populations, and the recommendation said so in those words rather than presenting it as a single product on a single schedule. It also carried three conditions: a mock-up fitted to a leaf from the thickest group and to the existing entrance door, approved and recorded and dated before manufacture; a survey reissued as a revision-controlled document that any change would replace rather than amend; and the key system transition written into the scope of works rather than left to the installer and the client's own key holder to negotiate on site.
What the recommendation did not do was promise that the product would fit every door. It said which populations it covered, which it did not, and what would happen to the ones it did not cover.
The route from the first survey to the handover record is short enough to draw, and drawing it exposed a stage I had been treating as obvious.
flowchart TD
A["Survey every opening"] --> B["Group openings into door populations"]
B --> C["Fix and date the levelling basis"]
C --> D["Read each return against the populations"]
D --> E["Restate scope, configuration and evidence"]
E --> F["Mark what could not be normalised"]
F --> G["Risk map with a named owner per row"]
G --> H["Recommendation with its conditions"]
H --> I["Mock-up fitted to a real leaf"]
I --> J["As-built record issued at handover"]
The stage that had been treated as obvious was the grouping. Two surveyors working the same corridor produced different populations, because one grouped by leaf construction and the other by thickness, and the two groupings gave the bidders different doors to price against.
Five checks before the sheet left my desk
These five are the ones I have never skipped on any tender, expressed the way a retrofit forces them to be expressed.
| Check | The retrofit version of the question | What an answer looked like on this job |
|---|---|---|
| Does the submittal state the dimensional information for the door that is on site | Does the answer name the measured door population rather than the door in the catalogue | Only two of four returns quoted a thickness range at all |
| Does the evidence name a document, a scope and a holder | Which document, for which variant, covering which scope, held by whom | Two returns offered a family-level reference with no variant named |
| Is the escape route locking arrangement the approved one, written down and dated | Which authority approved it, when, and is the record attached | Two of three escape doors came with no reference at all |
| Who owns the record after handover, and in what form | Which named person holds the survey, the approval and the handover record | Settled only after the question was put in writing |
| What does the client assume about the life of the installation, and is it written as the client's assumption | Whose figure is it, and whose hand is on it | The client's own figure, in the client's own words, with the date |
Each of those five is a question the panel can ask identically of every bidder on any project. What changes in retrofit is the answer: the first one needs the survey to exist before it can be asked, and the third one needs a door population rather than a product.
What a reviewer will ask
What if no bidder prices the doors as they are? Then the honest outcome is a return of the tender for clarification, with the survey attached as the reason. Comparing returns that each describe a different building produces a number that means nothing, and a number that means nothing is still a number that gets written in a board paper.
Can the panel normalise a difference that is really a difference in the assumption? No. It can ask the question, record the answer with its source, and then compare. It cannot average two incompatible door populations into one and present the result as a saving. That manoeuvre is where retrofit tenders lose their money.
Is it acceptable that the survey is wrong on the day? It is acceptable if the party that carried the survey is named and the consequences are written down, which is a contract question rather than a technical one. It is not acceptable if nobody knows whose survey it was.
How far does the sample go? It evidences fit and nothing more. It does not evidence performance over the life of the installation, it does not evidence how the door behaves on a panic, and it does not replace the authority's decision on the escape route.
What happens to the doors nobody quoted? On this job that was the hollow-core storage doors and the steel fire door, and the answer had to be written into the recommendation: either they are in the scope with a named solution, or they are excluded and named as excluded. Leaving them off both lists is how a building ends up with two doors nobody has accepted responsibility for.
What I changed in the tender that follows
The building was handed over and the doors were converted. The next tender on the same estate inherited four changes, and they all came out of the mistakes in this one.
The survey went into the tender pack, not after it. The tender asked bidders to price against a door population with measured values and to state, for any door their product could not cover, what they were offering instead. The basis sheet gained a first section for the door, and it was dated before the returns were opened rather than after. And the specification named the questions that only an existing building raises, so that bidders were asked them as part of the tender rather than discovered as variations on site.
Two problems survived the changes. The escape route still cannot be resolved by a tender panel, and the fire door still cannot be priced until someone with authority says what may be done to it. Both are now flagged in the tender as questions to the authorities, with the evidence each will be asked to produce, rather than as lines left for the installer to discover on site.
For the wider method this diary sits inside, the Common Bid Leveling Errors that Delay a Project piece works from the failure side and Bid Leveling in New Construction covers the case where the door does exist on paper. The evidence side is in Bid Leveling: Documents a Specifier Should Demand and the review format in Bid Leveling: Reviewer Checklist, while the submittal route through the same problem is set out in Submittal Process in Retrofit Projects. Published instruments for the field work are the Smart Lock Retrofit Project Planning guide, the Smart Lock Replacement Measurement Checklist, and the Retrofit Smart Lock vs New Lock Installation comparison for clients deciding what they are buying.
The practical next step for a reader who recognises this building is to send the measured door population and the document list to request a quote, so the bidders answer the same questions in the same order, and to have a sample fitted to a leaf from the thickest group before the tender closes, which is the Smart Lock Factory Sample Testing Guide method and can be arranged through order samples.
The durable lesson from this diary is short enough to keep in a notebook: in a retrofit, the first document a bidder should have seen was the door, and the panel that forgot it will spend the rest of the tender comparing quotations for a building that does not exist.

