Mockup and Sample Review: Reviewer Checklist
Physical review answers a narrower question than product acceptance. A mock-up or sample can expose geometry, interfaces, finish and handling; it cannot establish installed performance or authority approval. This mockup and sample review reviewer checklist turns that distinction into an auditable record for the door-hardware consultant. Use it during the physical lock mockup review to state what the sample demonstrated, what it did not, and who must close each remaining issue.
Direct answer. Short version — mockup and sample review reviewer checklist is treated here as mockup and sample review reviewer checklist first. mockup-and-sample-review comes second. The evidence for mockup and sample review reviewer checklist is named in the sections below. A mockup and sample review reviewer checklist gives the specifier working documents. mockup and sample review reviewer checklist is the document that decides the requirement. That is what mockup and sample review reviewer checklist turns into.
CONFIRM-WITH-LOCAL-BUILDING-CONTROL: Confirm which authority, if any, reviews the installed door set; this checklist records physical sample evidence only.
Memo scope and decision boundary
This memo supports a review that connects the client, installer and supplier without replacing site verification. Its decision is whether the sample is acceptable as evidence for the stated review scope. What the specification covers is in the smart door locks.
| Memo field | Working position |
|---|---|
| Purpose | Reconcile physical evidence with the specified door set and submittal |
| Review owner | Door-hardware consultant or other named reviewer |
| Decision audience | Client’s design and procurement representatives |
| Evidence cutoff | Fit, finish, interfaces and handling within the agreed review conditions |
| Explicit exclusion | Installed performance, site conditions and authority acceptance |
Identify the door leaf, frame, hardware and locks by their schedule references. A sample without a traceable door-set reference cannot be compared reliably.
Evidence the sample can and cannot settle
A mock-up is evidence of fit and finish when its conditions are documented. It is not a performance certificate. Keep the evidence boundary visible so a reviewer does not convert a favorable visual inspection into an unsupported acceptance.
| Evidence area | What the sample may establish | What remains unresolved |
|---|---|---|
| Dimensional fit | Whether the sample interfaces match the stated dimensions | Whether the actual door and frame match those dimensions |
| Faceplate and strike | Whether the supplied closing-edge components form a matched pair | Alignment after installation on site |
| Finish | Whether the physical sample visually matches the agreed reference | The approved production finish unless separately confirmed |
| Operation | How the included components operated during the agreed check | Performance under site power, network and usage conditions |
| Accessories | Which parts were present for the review | Whether every required interface is supplied |
| Documentation | Whether the sample can be reconciled to a dated submittal | Whether the delivered product will match that revision |
Smart lock sample approval therefore means that the sample passed the agreed fit-and-finish checks within the recorded conditions. It does not approve the installation, the complete submittal or an unseen product revision.
Intake gate before the sample arrives
Treat missing information as a review finding rather than filling gaps during the meeting.
- Identify the door set. Record the opening reference, door schedule, frame type and intended lock arrangement.
- Reconcile the sample. Capture the manufacturer, model or SKU, sample identifier, finish and hardware revision against the current submittal and dated product page.
- Obtain dimensional evidence. Require the backset, bore diameter, bolt-to-bore distance, faceplate and strike references, units and stated tolerances.
- Identify the finish. Provide the RAL or colour reference, approved sample and any assembly instructions governing concealed or adjacent surfaces.
- Set the review criteria. List which items must be inspected physically and which remain document or authority reviews.
- Assemble the door hardware submittal record. Include the review request, product evidence, drawings, door-set references and outstanding questions.
- Schedule the record owner. Name the reviewer, attendees, evidence custodian and person authorized to close actions.
The supporting evidence request can be cross-referenced with Mockup and Sample Review: Documents a Specifier Should Demand.
Review workflow and stop points
The workflow should expose incomplete evidence before it reaches a physical approval decision.
flowchart TD
A[Set review scope] --> B{Evidence package complete}
B -->|No| C[Return incomplete package]
B -->|Yes| D{Sample identity matched}
D -->|No| E[Hold sample comparison]
D -->|Yes| F[Check fit and finish]
F --> G{Exceptions recorded}
G -->|No| H[Record approval decision]
G -->|Yes| I[Assign corrective actions]
I --> J{Actions closed}
J -->|No| K[Keep decision conditional]
J -->|Yes| H
A return-for-completion decision preserves the original review scope. A conditional decision identifies the exact condition, owner and evidence required for closure. Neither decision should conceal an unresolved identity or dimensional discrepancy.
Using the reviewer checklist line by line
This mockup and sample review reviewer checklist supports fit and finish verification without implying a test of the installed assembly. Record the evidence reference beside each result so a later reader can reconstruct the decision.
| Review check | Evidence entered | Pass condition |
|---|---|---|
| Scope and door set | Opening, schedule and drawing references | All references identify the same door set |
| Sample identity | Manufacturer, model or SKU, sample ID and revision | Details reconcile to the submitted package |
| Backset | Distance from door edge to spindle or cylinder centre | Datum and unit match the door documentation |
| Bore diameter | Separate dimensional callout | Value, unit and tolerance are stated independently |
| Bolt-to-bore distance | Separate dimensional callout | Value is not inferred from the bore diameter |
| Faceplate and strike | Paired component references | Supplied pair matches the intended assembly |
| Case configuration | Mortise, rim or multipoint identification | Configuration agrees with the submittal |
| Door context | Thickness, material and relevant clearances | Mock-up conditions represent the stated design |
| Finish reference | RAL or colour reference and physical sample | Sample is compared with the stated reference |
| Physical fit | Observations at each door or frame interface | No unexplained interference or mismatch remains |
| Operating check | Agreed sequence and observed return positions | Result is limited to the agreed manual check |
| Accessories | Included reader, spindle, strike or other components | Physical contents match the review inventory |
| Evidence package | Dated product page and supporting documents | Each product fact has a traceable source |
A blank field means the item was not reviewed. Do not convert a blank into an assumed pass. If the sample differs from the submittal, record the difference and reopen the relevant submittal item.
Decision comparison and sample review
The reviewer should choose a decision that matches the evidence rather than the desired schedule outcome.
| Decision | Minimum evidence | Recorded consequence | Next control |
|---|---|---|---|
| Accept for stated scope | All scoped checks completed with no open exception | Sample evidence is accepted for that scope | Retain the package and closure record |
| Accept with conditions | Fit and identity are established, with bounded exceptions | Approval applies only to the recorded conditions | Assign owner, due date and closure evidence |
| Return for revision | Missing or conflicting evidence prevents comparison | No sample decision is issued | Correct the package and repeat the review |
| Reject the sample | Identity or design conflict cannot be reconciled within scope | Sample is excluded from the evidence set | Record the conflict and initiate a new review |
The decision must distinguish sample acceptance from product or installation approval. The submittal is not approved until the review is recorded and dated.
Discrepancy and exception log
Attach the exception log to the review record. Use one entry for each observable difference so that closure can be traced without rereading meeting notes.
| Log field | Required entry |
|---|---|
| Finding ID | Unique reference |
| Location | Opening and door-set reference |
| Observation | Plain description of the condition |
| Requirement | Drawing, dimension or finish reference |
| Proposed correction | Specific action offered for review |
| Owner | Named person responsible |
| Due date | Agreed closure date |
| Status | Open, verification pending or closed |
| Closure evidence | Document, photograph or revised record |
| Reviewer confirmation | Name and dated confirmation |
Keep observations separate from conclusions. For example, record the observed gap before proposing a revised dimension or alternative component.
Routing unresolved questions
Some findings need evidence from outside the review meeting.
- Site conditions: Use an Office Smart Lock Site Survey or Smart Lock Retrofit Site Survey to obtain the door and frame facts needed for comparison.
- Product evidence: Give the supplier a precise question and request a dated, revision-specific source rather than a verbal capability statement.
- Authority decisions: Keep installed-door acceptance outside the sample record and route it to the responsible reviewer.
- Finish decisions: Ask the client or design lead to confirm the governing colour reference and the surfaces included in that reference.
CONFIRM-PER-SUPPLIER: Confirm any connected-function or accessory capability against the dated product page for the specific SKU.
CONFIRM-WITH-LOCAL-FIRE-AUTHORITY: Confirm any fire-door or egress-related acceptance separately; the sample review does not decide it.
CONFIRM-WITH-LOCAL-ACCESS-CONSULTANT: Confirm the operable-part and access criteria for the installed assembly.
Build the mock-up approval log
The reviewer should create the log as the meeting proceeds rather than reconstruct it afterward. The wider sequence is set out in Mockup and Sample Review: A Smart Lock Specifier Guide.
Include these fields:
- Review identifier, revision, date, location and attendee roles
- Door-set, sample and submittal references
- Evidence index and photograph references
- Check results and discrepancy identifiers
- Decision, conditions and action owners
- Final file location and responsible record holder
A photograph shows the finish; it does not specify it. Preserve the approved reference alongside the image, and preserve the dated review record alongside both. If the sample is returned, transferred or replaced, record that custody change so a later reader knows which physical evidence supported the decision.
Readers comparing approaches usually start with smart lock manufacturer for apartment projects. That is the same question mockup and sample review reviewer checklist has to answer here.
Closeout and final sign-off
Close the review only after each accepted condition has closure evidence and the reviewer has confirmed it.
| Role | Record before closeout |
|---|---|
| Reviewer | Completed checks, decision and exception history |
| Installer | Dimensional or fit input required for site feasibility |
| Client or design lead | Finish and selection acceptance within its authority |
| Supplier | Revised evidence and corrections attributable to the supplied sample |
Issue the completed reviewer checklist with the submittal record, not as an informal attachment. A clear boundary lets the client reuse the decision, lets the installer identify field checks and gives the supplier an exact route for closing the next revision.
Put the answer on paper and request a quote against that document.

