Ansi/bhma A156.14 Versus ANSI/BHMA A156.23: Which One Applies to Your Smart Lock Door
For ansi bhma a156 14 versus ansi bhma a156 23 applicability, classify the hardware before asking a supplier for evidence. ANSI/BHMA A156.14 covers push and pull devices used as exit devices, while ANSI/BHMA A156.23 covers electromagnetic locks. A smart-lock label does not determine either scope. Use this playbook to route the door, demand the appropriate evidence, and prevent a component report from being mistaken for approval of the complete opening.
Direct answer. The phrase ansi bhma a156 14 versus ansi bhma a156 23 applicability
1. Route the door by hardware function
Ask what physically holds or releases the door. Do not begin with the words “smart lock.” For document control, retain the comparison key ansi-bhma-a156-14 on the worksheet, but base the technical decision on function.
| Door opening or hardware decision | Applicable route | Evidence to request | Scope boundary |
|---|---|---|---|
| Push bar or pull device operating as an exit device | ANSI/BHMA A156.14 | Test report or certificate for the exact device | Does not test an electromagnetic holding function |
| Electrically controlled magnet holding a door closed | ANSI/BHMA A156.23 | Evidence covering holding force, duty, and intended environment | Does not cover push or pull exit hardware |
| Smart lock serving ordinary access control | Identify the actual lock function first | Evidence matched to the lock body, electric strike, reader, or assembly | No single designation proves an entire access-control system |
| Fire-rated, accessible, or egress door | Add project-specific requirements | Assembly evidence and project approval records | Hardware scope does not establish opening compliance |
A156.14 is the exit device standard when a physical push or pull device releases the latch. A156.23 is the electromagnetic lock standard when an electrically controlled magnet holds the door. If both devices are present, request separate evidence for each function. Smart lock door applicability is therefore settled by hardware role, not branding or communications. The build options sit in the smart door locks.
flowchart TD
A[Identify the hardware function] --> B{What holds or releases the door?}
B -->|Push or pull exit device| C[Use ANSI BHMA A156.14 scope]
B -->|Electromagnetic holding lock| D[Use ANSI BHMA A156.23 scope]
C --> E[Request scoped product evidence]
D --> E
CONFIRM-WITH-LOCAL-AUTHORITY: Confirm project-specific egress, fire-door, and accessibility requirements with the authority having jurisdiction and the project’s qualified reviewers.
2. Keep four evidence documents separate
A supplier’s statement that it has a standard must be resolved into a specific document.
| Document | What it establishes | What to demand |
|---|---|---|
| Test report | Someone tested a sample | Sample identity, tested product, standard edition, and result |
| Certificate | A body attests conformity | Scope, verifiable number, validity, and covered model or variant |
| Declaration of conformity | The manufacturer or importer makes its own legal claim | Named legal issuer, signature, date, and referenced requirements |
| Marking | A regulatory mark appears on the product or label | Clear image of the mark and supporting documentation |
A standard describes what it tests; it never turns a component scope into site approval. Certification status is CONFIRM-PER-SUPPLIER. Treat “we have A156.23” as incomplete until the supplier identifies the document and explains its scope.
CONFIRM-WITH-LOCAL-AUTHORITY: Confirm which declaration and marking obligations apply to the shipment, project, and destination market; the four documents are not interchangeable.
3. Request evidence at the right rung
Use this sequence for every proposed device:
- Name the configuration. Record the exact product or variant, its role at the door, and its operating environment.
- Confirm the designation. Ask for the current edition, published title, and scope. Route clause-level questions to the published standard text because editions change.
- Locate the evidence rung. The useful ladder runs from a marketing image to a self-declared declaration of conformity, a test report on a sample, a third-party certificate with scope and number, a certificate covering the exact SKU or variant, and audit or production-control evidence.
- Match scope to the claim. Check that the document covers the actual product, function, and intended environment rather than merely citing the designation.
- Record ownership. Note the evidence holder, issue or validity dates, unresolved conditions, and the person responsible for closing each gap.
Use Ansi/bhma A156.14 for Smart Locks: Scope, Tests and What the Standard Never Proves before treating a designation as product approval. For an existing opening, pair that scope check with Ansi/bhma A156.14 When Retrofitting Smart Locks Onto Existing Doors.
4. Resolve adjacent door and system questions
Do not make A156.23 a generic “electric lock” requirement or use A156.14 to cover a magnet. Other standards address adjacent functions: A156.25 covers electrified locking devices whose electrical function is not covered elsewhere, A156.31 covers electric strikes and frame-mounted actuators, A156.35 covers access-control power supplies, and UL 294 addresses access-control system units.
For field verification, use the Office Smart Lock Site Survey and Smart Lock Retrofit Site Survey to document the actual opening. Check whether egress hardware, fire-door components, and accessible operable parts introduce separate project questions. NFPA 101, NFPA 80, and ADA / ANSI A117.1 address those issues in their own contexts rather than replacing either BHMA hardware standard.
Readers comparing approaches usually start with smart lock emergency power security. That is the same question ansi bhma a156 14 versus ansi bhma a156 23 applicability has to answer here.CONFIRM-WITH-LOCAL-AUTHORITY: Confirm the applicable editions, project requirements, and assembly responsibilities with local reviewers before approving the complete door.
5. Finalize the applicability record
For ansi bhma a156 14 versus ansi bhma a156 23 applicability, sign off only when the record explains why the selected designation matches the hardware and why other documents are unnecessary.
| Required record | Minimum entry |
|---|---|
| Opening | Door ID, frame type, and hardware function |
| Standard | Designation, current edition, and scope rationale |
| Product | Exact model or variant and relevant configuration |
| Evidence | Document type, issuer, number, sample, scope, and validity |
| Declaration | Legal issuer, signature, and date where applicable |
| Approval | Owner, unresolved conditions, and closure date |
Do not close qualification with a marketing image alone. The procurement record should show which evidence supports the purchased configuration and which separate approval remains outstanding.
6. Issue the supplier request and retain the answer
Send one line per opening asking the supplier to:
- Identify the proposed standard and current edition.
- Explain the hardware-function basis for that selection.
- Attach the relevant test report, certificate, declaration of conformity, or marking evidence.
- State the exact model, variant, scope, number, issuer, and validity covered.
- Identify any sample, environmental, configuration, or production-control limitation.
- List approvals that must come from the project authority rather than the supplier.
Use Ansi/bhma A156.14 in a Smart Lock Tender Pack: The Evidence Checklist to turn those answers into tender attachments. Attach the door schedule, product documentation, and evidence register to the RFQ, then require a line-by-line supplier response before approval. This keeps the technical scope, documentary proof, and project responsibility attached to the same door rather than scattered across separate claims.
Put the answer on paper and request a quote against that document.

