En 1154 versus en 1155 applicability: EN 1154 and EN 1155 cover different door hardware, so this guide shows procurement which one applies to a smart lock door.

Δημοσιεύτηκε στις: Ιαν 18, 2023

EN 1154 Versus EN 1155: Which One Applies to Your Smart Lock Door

EN 1154 Versus EN 1155: Which One Applies to Your Smart Lock Door

Procurement managers receive the en 1154 versus en 1155 applicability question in its least useful form: a single line in a supplier questionnaire asking a hardware maker to confirm "EN 1154 or EN 1155 compliance" for a battery-driven smart lock programme. The line cannot be answered with one designation, because the two standards cover different pieces of hardware on the same leaf, and neither of them evaluates a lock.

Direct answer. To put it plainly: en 1154 versus en 1155 applicability has to hold for en 1154 versus en 1155 applicability. en-1154 has to hold at the same time. The sections below describe the order en 1154 versus en 1155 applicability is settled in. an en 1154 versus en 1155 applicability turns conformity language into requests a buyer can send. en 1154 versus en 1155 applicability is where those en 1154 versus en 1155 applicability requests get written down.

  • What is in the supplier file — supplier declarations and drawings for en 1154 versus en 1155 applicability
  • What needs certification — third-party certificates covering the exact scope of en-1154
  • What to obtain — the document set that matches the SKU behind en 1154 versus en 1155 applicability
  • en 1154 versus en 1155 applicability runs this sequence, and en 1154 is the record it produces.

The short answer sits in the closing behaviour. EN 1154 covers controlled door closing devices, where the energy that closes the leaf comes from the user or from the device's own spring, with spring hinges sitting outside its scope. EN 1155 covers electrically powered hold-open devices for swing doors, the mechanism that holds a leaf open and releases it on command, and it does not answer the question of a manual closer. So the en 1154 versus en 1155 applicability decision is made by what the door does when nobody touches it, not by what is bolted to the stile.

Meanwhile the smart lock keeps its own file. A battery-driven lock with a motor driving a spindle sits in the electromechanically operated locks and striking plates family, EN 14846, rather than the mechanically operated family of EN 12209. A supplier asked for "an EN 1154 test report" on a lock has been mis-filed, and a supplier that answers with a closer certificate has answered a question nobody put. This article belongs to the en-1154 cluster of the standards library, where the closing-hardware question is tracked separately from the locking question.

What follows is a seven-stage qualification sequence, written for the procurement manager who owns the file rather than the engineer who owns the drawing. Each stage has an entry condition, a written artefact and a gate. Use it to keep smart lock door hardware standards from collapsing into a single checkbox.

Stage 1 — Build the door schedule before opening the product list

No hardware standard can be applied to "a smart lock door" as a category, because the category hides the only facts that matter. Before a single SKU is discussed, produce a door schedule with one row per leaf and describe each leaf in the language the standards themselves use.

Field in the door scheduleWhat it settles before any product is chosen
Leaf type and swing directionSingle swing, double swing, sliding or revolving decides which hardware designations are even in play
Leaf width and leaf massCloses the size band of any closer or hold-open device that can be offered
Self-closing or free swingSeparates a controlled closing device question from a hold-open question
Hold-open arrangementManual hold-open, electromagnetically held, or released by the fire alarm
Fire door or smoke door statusA fire-rated leaf moves the hold-open question to EN 14637 and the assembly listing
Escape route roleAn escape door pulls EN 179 or EN 1125 into the same package
Power available at the head of the frameMains, battery or none decides the electrical regime the hold-open device sits in
Hardware already installed on siteA retrofit line changes which component is replaced and which evidence already exists
The smart lock on the leafKeeps EN 14846 work separate from the closing hardware work

The schedule is also the split point for the whole programme. Two work streams run in parallel: closing and hold-open hardware on one side, the locking device on the other. Keeping the rows separate is what stops a door closer certificate from being filed as proof of a smart lock, which is the single most common filing error in door closing device procurement. The earlier published note on this is Glass Door Smart Lock Price Guide. What the specification covers is in the smart door locks.

Two columns decide most rows on their own. Where the leaf closes itself, the closer enters the file. Where the leaf is deliberately held open, an electrical hold-open question opens. Where both are true, expect a closer body with an integrated powered hold-open, and expect to need two pieces of evidence from one document.

Stage 2 — Name the closing behaviour in one sentence

For every leaf in the schedule, write one sentence in the form "the leaf returns to the latch when a person pushes it and lets go", or "the leaf stands open until a signal releases it", or "the leaf is part of a fire door assembly and the hold-open releases on alarm". The mapping from that sentence to a designation is short, and it is the whole answer to the en 1154 versus en 1155 applicability question.

flowchart TD
    A[Start with the door schedule row] --> B[Record how the leaf closes]
    B -->|Closes itself from user power| C[EN 1154 closer path]
    B -->|Held open by an electric device| D[EN 1155 hold open path]
    B -->|Closer with integrated powered hold open| E[Ask which scope covers which function]
    C --> F[Lock function handled under EN 14846]
    D --> G[Fire or smoke leaf moves the answer to EN 14637]
    E --> F
    G --> H[Audit the evidence before the order is released]
Door as builtDesignation in scope for that itemWhat that designation does not answerEvidence to demand
Self-closing swing leaf, no powered hold-openEN 1154 for the controlled door closing deviceThe locking device; spring hinges sit outside its scopeNamed document for the closer, with size band and current edition stated
Swing leaf held open by an electrically powered deviceEN 1155 for the hold-open deviceManual closers; the locking deviceNamed document for the hold-open device, with the power arrangement stated
Fire or smoke door assembly with an electrically controlled hold-openEN 14637 for the hold-open systemNon-fire doors; battery-only systems are explicitly outside its own scope statementSystem-level evidence covering the alarm interface and the maintenance regime
Battery-driven smart lock on any of the aboveEN 14846 for the electromechanical locking functionRadio and EMC; fire resistance; escape-device logicPer-SKU evidence from the lock maker, separate from the closing hardware file
Double swing leaf with a coordinatorEN 1158, once the published title and scope are checkedLock function of any kindPublished scope text plus the coordinator's own document

The third row deserves emphasis because it is where smart lock programmes get into trouble. A powered hold-open on a fire door is not simply an EN 1155 device with a fire label attached. EN 14637 is the designation that carries requirements, tests, application and maintenance for electrically controlled hold-open systems on fire and smoke door assemblies, including the interface to the fire detection and alarm system and the expectation of mains power. A battery-only hold-open arrangement is explicitly outside that scope statement, so the substitution question has to go to the fire assessment authority for the building rather than being settled in a supplier email.

Stage 3 — Split the leaf into three hardware files

The same door generates three separate evidence files, and the mistake this stage prevents is treating one supplier's certificate as if it covered all three.

The first file is closing hardware. It holds the EN 1154 door closer, the EN 1155 electric hold-open device where one exists, and a coordinator on a double door where the published title and scope for EN 1158 confirm it applies.

The second file is the lock. It holds the EN 14846 smart lock evidence for the electromechanical locking function, cylinder evidence under EN 1303 where a cylinder is supplied, mechatronic cylinder scope under EN 15684 once its published title and scope are checked, and multi-point scope under EN 15685 for the same reason. EN 12209 belongs in this file only where a lock is genuinely mechanical, because that designation does not answer electromechanical or electronically driven locking.

The third file is the assembly and the market regime. It holds the fire door assembly listing and the EN 1634-1 evidence route for a rated leaf, the radio and EMC paperwork for any wireless component, and the destination-country conformity route. That file is where the question of whether a given device is sold as a construction product under the EU construction-products route is answered, and that answer is a per-product question rather than a general rule.

Stage 4 — Read the scope statement before the marking

Editions change, so write "the current edition of EN 1154" and route every clause-level claim back to the published standard text. A supplier's PDF that quotes a clause number without naming the edition is not evidence; it is a fragment from an unknown vintage.

Classification language carries the same trap. EN 12209 is described with an eleven-digit classification code and use categories, while EN 1154 products are marked with class and grade numbers of their own. A sales email that says "grade two" tells you nothing until you can point at the document it came from and the edition that defined it. The published companion piece Decoding EN 1154 Class and Grade Numbers for Door Hardware is the right companion read for that step, and EN 1154 for Smart Locks: Scope, Tests and What the Standard Never Proves sets out why the scope statement has to be read in full before any of those numbers mean anything.

Watch for citations that arrive already mis-filed. EN 1935 is a standard for single-axis hinges, yet it turns up in locker and hardware schedules as if it were a latch requirement. EN 12361 covers electronically controlled door opening interlock devices for controlled-access situations and is frequently cited as though it governed ordinary smart lock function. EN 15684 and EN 15685 need their published titles and scopes checked in the current edition before they are used at all. Push back on any of these by asking for the published scope line, not by arguing from memory.

CONFIRM-WITH-LOCAL-BUILDING-CONTROL: any national deviation, amendment or local requirement that modifies how a closing device or a hold-open system is installed on your building is confirmed with the authority that signs off in your market before the specification is frozen.

Stage 5 — Put the written question into the RFQ

The answer should be written by the supplier and attached to the quotation, not inferred by you from a catalogue line. Put the question in the request for quotation in a form that forces structure, and require the answer to be per configuration rather than per brand.

Write this questionA weak answerThe answer that closes the file
Which designation and current edition does the claim useEN 1154 compliantThe designation with its current edition and the scope it rests on
Which document carries the claimAre you certified for this scope?A named document type, a number where one exists, a scope and a date
Does the scope cover our leaf size and configurationSuitable for all doorsA written statement tying size band and configuration to the document
Which production site is coveredFactory directThe site named in the document and any production-control evidence attached
Which function of the body does the document coverThe whole deviceA statement separating the closing function from any powered hold-open function

The clause-writing detail that saves weeks sits in the companion pieces Closers, Hold-Opens and Smart Locks: Where the EN 1154 Clause Belongs and EN 1154 in a Smart Lock Tender Pack: The Evidence Checklist. Write the requirement once per hardware file. If the quote contains a closer, the closer file carries the EN 1154 question; the hold-open file carries the EN 1155 question; the lock file carries the EN 14846 question. One merged requirement produces one merged answer, and a merged answer is exactly what you cannot audit.

Stage 6 — Audit the answer against the evidence ladder

Rank every answer you receive before you accept it. The ladder runs from the weakest evidence to the strongest, and the point of ranking is that a supplier can satisfy you at rung two and still fail you at installation.

  • Rung 1: marketing image. A brochure photograph or a rendered detail carries no scope at all.
  • Rung 2: self-declared DoC. The manufacturer or importer makes the claim in its own name and on its own responsibility.
  • Rung 3: test report on a sample. Someone tested one sample and wrote the result up.
  • Rung 4: third-party certificate with scope and number. A named body attests conformity within a stated scope.
  • Rung 5: certificate covering the exact SKU and variant you are buying. The product on your order appears inside the scope, at the size and configuration you ordered.
  • Rung 6: audit and production-control evidence that keeps the result valid after the sample passed. The route by which the certificate stays alive across production batches. For en 1154 versus en 1155 applicability, the position on this ladder is what the purchase decision turns on.

The recurring commercial failure mode is buying at rung two or rung three and discovering on site that nothing exists at rung five. The audit step is short and mechanical: search the issuing body's public register using the certificate number, read the scope line against your leaf size and configuration, confirm the named production site matches the one shipping the goods, check the validity dates, and check that the certificate holder is the legal entity on your invoice. If the answer is a test report, ask for the full report rather than a summary page; the walkthrough in Reading an EN 1154 Test Report Page by Page: A Smart Lock Buyer Walkthrough shows which pages carry the scope and which carry only sample data.

Markings are a separate category again and they are the easiest to over-read. CE, UKCA, RCM, KC and G-Mark printed on a product or label tell you that a mark is present. They do not tell you which standard sits behind it, they do not carry a scope, and they are not interchangeable with the certificate. Three Ways EN 1154 Evidence Disappoints Smart Lock Buyers covers the recurring ways this file goes wrong after signature.

CONFIRM-PER-SUPPLIER: all conformity status in this article is stated as a question to ask and a document to demand. Nothing here is a certification claim for any product, and every certificate, report or declaration must be confirmed per supplier against a named, dated document.

Stage 7 — Hand over, adjust, and keep the record

Installation is the last chance to catch a mismatch between the schedule and the evidence, so treat it as an audit event rather than a handover formality. Confirm that the device's size band covers the leaf width and mass recorded at Stage 1. For a spring-hinged leaf, confirm that the hinge arrangement was assessed on its own terms, because spring hinges sit outside the EN 1154 scope. Record the adjusted closing and latching speed, the backcheck setting and the latch projection as the manufacturer's instructions specify, and photograph the finished installation with the device markings legible.

Accessible doors add a separate constraint that belongs to the accessibility regime in your market, not to either designation in this article. Operable parts, closing speed and the force needed to open the door are governed by the local accessibility rule and the closing hardware has to be set to suit it.

CONFIRM-WITH-LOCAL-ACCESSIBILITY: the opening force, closing speed and single-mechanism operation requirements that apply to your doors come from the accessibility rule in force in your jurisdiction and are confirmed with the enforcing authority for that rule.

On a fire door, hardware is tested as part of the door assembly, which is why the concept of a standalone "lock fire certificate" does not exist. Confirm that the hardware fitted to the leaf is the hardware named in the assembly listing, and confirm with the fire assessment authority how any change to the closing hardware interacts with that listing. EN 14637 places maintenance inside its own scope, so request the maintenance plan and the interval stated by the current edition and by the manufacturer's instructions, together with the record that shows the system was actually checked.

CONFIRM-WITH-LOCAL-FIRE-ASSESSMENT: any powered hold-open arrangement on a fire or smoke door, including a battery-only arrangement, is confirmed with the authority that signs off on the fire strategy before it is specified.

Keep the file alive after handover. Hold the door schedule, the supplier's written answers, the documents themselves, the serial numbers of the installed devices, the installation date and the maintenance log in one place. Where the programme records door events, treat those logs as personal data and settle retention, hosting location and deletion before go-live rather than after the first request.

Where the smart lock's own evidence sits

The closing hardware file is finished at Stage 7, but the lock file runs in parallel and it answers different questions. EN 14846 is the electromechanical lock standard for a battery-driven product, and it is the closer fit for the mechanical-electrical locking function than EN 12209, which describes mechanically operated locks, latches and locking plates and does not answer electronically driven locking. Where a separate cylinder is supplied, EN 1303 governs that component. Lever handles and knobs fall under EN 1906, and a hinge remains a hinge under EN 1935.

Radio, electrical safety and battery questions sit alongside, not inside, either closing designation. A mains-powered gateway and a battery lock can sit in different regimes, and the radio regime applies to whichever component carries the transmitter. The forwarder will ask for lithium transport evidence for any battery-containing shipment, and the installer will ask for the ingress and mechanical-impact codes quoted as two letters rather than as prose. Where a specifier asks whether the lock joins a wireless ecosystem, the answer is a question to put in writing rather than a sentence to write on a product page: Matter, Thread, Zigbee, Z-Wave, Apple Home Key, HomeKit and UWB are ecosystems you may be asked about, so confirm on the dated product page for the specific SKU which of them, if any, applies.

Two companion pieces cover the mechanics of that file. EN 1154 When Retrofitting Smart Locks Onto Existing Doors covers what changes when the leaf is already in service, and Who Pays for EN 1154 Evidence in a Smart Lock OEM Programme covers the commercial allocation of that cost between factory, distributor and integrator, which is often the hidden reason a programme stalls at Stage 6.

Doors that never enter the EN 1154 or EN 1155 lane

Some leaves in a smart lock programme have nothing to do with this decision. An escape door with a single-lever exit device is governed by EN 179, while a door with a horizontally actuated panic bar is governed by EN 1125, and neither designation is answered by either closing standard. Sliding and revolving leaves, gate leaves and barriers have their own routes. A double swing leaf with a coordinator needs its own check against the published title and scope for EN 1158. Where the lock on the leaf is purely mechanical with no drive, EN 12209 is the correct family, and EN 15685 is the one to check when the locking perimeter is multi-point rather than single point.

Regional practice also changes what you are asked to produce. EN 1154 in Nigeria and West Africa Purchasing Practice: What Buyers Are Asked to Produce shows how a destination-market pre-shipment route changes the order of the evidence file, and the principle travels: the technical designation on the drawing does not remove a destination-country conformity obligation.

When the programme is not working to the European

Outside Europe the designations on this page do not transfer, and the equivalent questions are asked in a different vocabulary. Door controls and closers are covered by ANSI/BHMA A156.4, electromagnetic locks by ANSI/BHMA A156.23, electrified locking devices by ANSI/BHMA A156.25, power locks by UL 1034, and access control units by UL 294. Fire door hardware falls under the installation and maintenance rules of NFPA 80, egress and locking arrangements sit with NFPA 101, and operable parts come under ADA and ANSI A117.1.

CONFIRM-WITH-LOCAL-NORTH-AMERICA: the door-control designation, the fire door installation rules, the egress locking arrangement and the accessibility limits that apply in your jurisdiction are confirmed with the authority that publishes or enforces them, because the published text and its editions change.

The sequence on one page

flowchart LR
    S1[Stage 1 door schedule] --> S2[Stage 2 closing behaviour sentence]
    S2 --> S3[Stage 3 split the hardware files]
    S3 --> S4[Stage 4 scope text and current edition]
    S4 --> S5[Stage 5 written rfq question]
    S5 --> S6[Stage 6 evidence ladder audit]
    S6 --> S7[Stage 7 handover adjustment and maintenance]

Readers comparing approaches usually start with smart lock anti tamper design. That is the same question en 1154 versus en 1155 applicability has to answer here.

StageGate that must be passedWho signs
1Every leaf described in the scheduleQuantity surveyor with the door supplier
2One closing-behaviour sentence per leafDoor hardware engineer
3Three hardware files opened per programmeProcurement manager
4Published scope text filed for each designation in useTechnical reviewer
5RFQ carries one structured question per fileProcurement manager
6Answer ranked on the evidence ladder and register-checkedQuality or compliance reviewer
7Installation record and maintenance plan openedSite manager with the service contractor

When the answer comes back "both"

Expect it. A door that closes itself and is also held open by a powered device produces an EN 1154 requirement for the closing function and an EN 1155 requirement for the hold-open function, and the two may be answered by one body or by two devices. The answer that closes the file is a statement of which document covers which function of that body, with the scope line quoted for each. Record it as two lines in the evidence register even when the supplier sent one PDF.

This overlaps with the earlier coverage in smart lock anti picking design. That is the same question en 1154 versus en 1155 applicability has to answer here.The closing position is equally practical. When the leaf is fire rated and the hold-open is electrically controlled, EN 14637 governs that system and EN 1155 alone will not carry the claim. When the lock is battery driven, EN 14846 carries the locking function and neither closing designation carries it. Once those three lines are separated on the specification, the remaining work is documentary, and documentary work is where it should stay.

Send the door schedule and the product list before you send the purchase order. With the leaf facts, the locking device and the hold-open arrangement in one place, the applicable designation for each item can be fixed in writing, and the question to each supplier can be issued as a single structured clause set rather than a conversation that has to be repeated at every gate.

Put the answer on paper and request a quote against that document.

Το καλάθι σας
Η εμπειρία σας σε αυτόν τον ιστότοπο θα βελτιωθεί με την ενεργοποίηση των cookies Πολιτική cookies
Chat on WhatsApp