A smart lock mortise compatibility guide is not a single dimensional table. Each pillar produces its own verification artefact; the five artefacts together

نُشر في: فبراير 27, 2026

Smart Lock Mortise Compatibility Guide

Smart Lock Mortise Compatibility Guide

A smart lock mortise compatibility guide is not a single dimensional table. It is the five-pillar qualification discipline a system integrator, a property owner, or a procurement lead runs to decide whether a specific mortise smart lock will physically and operationally fit a specific door — before the door is cut, before the lock is ordered, before the installer climbs the ladder. The five pillars are: door envelope fit, mortise pocket geometry, spindle-cylinder-faceplate alignment, door-material and structural compatibility, and per-model evidence. Each pillar produces its own verification artefact; the five artefacts together constitute the compatibility sign-off folder that travels with the lock from the supplier's drawing to the installer's handover.

The compatibility decision lives in the gap between two documents the buyer has never read together: the supplier's per-model drawing (the lock side) and the door survey or door schedule (the door side). If the integrator treats those documents as a single matrix — pocket length to door thickness, centre-of-spindle to handle height, deadbolt throw to strike depth — the procurement program stops being a sequence of single-question RFIs and becomes an evidence chain. The five pillars below describe what that evidence chain looks like in practice, what each pillar catches, what each pillar refuses to ship without, and how the pillars hand off to one another.

Distinct from the measurement sibling at Smart Lock Mortise Measurement (Smart Lock Mortise Measurement), which delivers numbered governance clauses for the pocket cut itself, this article delivers the qualification discipline that has to pass before those clauses are written. The matrix sibling at Smart Lock Door Compatibility Matrix (Smart Lock Door Compatibility Matrix) is the cross-model comparison instrument; the mortise measurement sibling at Smart Lock Mortise Measurement (Smart Lock Mortise Measurement) is the dimensional protocol; this guide is the decision framework that says "this lock against this door is or is not compatible, and here is the evidence we used."

Why this is not the dimensional table (and why the distinction matters)

The buyer who pulls up a single dimensional matrix — "lock body 220 × 80 × 18 mm, fits pocket of 222 × 82 × 20 mm" — and treats it as the compatibility decision has made four mistakes in one glance. The dimensional matrix answers only pillar 2 (pocket geometry). It does not answer pillar 1 (door thickness, backset, edge squareness), pillar 3 (whether the spindle, cylinder, and faceplate align in the operating plane), pillar 4 (whether the door material cooperates with the lock body), or pillar 5 (whether the supplier's published drawing actually says what the dimensional table asserts). Compatibility is the intersection of five gates; passing one gate is passing one gate.

The five pillars also resist a different kind of over-simplification, the "the lock is universal" claim. Mortise smart locks are not universal. A hotel-class mortise lock is not a glass-door mortise lock. A 36–100 mm door-thickness band is not a "fits all doors" band. A steel-cored fire-rated door is not a wood-core guest-room door. Per-model compatibility exists because per-model mechanical envelopes exist, and the per-model envelope the supplier publishes is the source of truth the buyer has to read against the per-door survey the integrator runs on site.

The reason this matters commercially: every compatibility decision made on a single dimensional check, made late, or made against a generic template turns into one of three expensive outcomes on site — a pocket that has to be recut, a lock that has to be re-ordered, or a door that has to be replaced. The five pillars turn those three outcomes from "discovered during installation" into "prevented during qualification."

Pillar 1 — Door envelope fit

Purpose: decide whether the lock's door-thickness band, backset range, and edge geometry can accept the door the integrator has in front of them.

The door envelope pillar is where the lock first meets the door. Three independent measurements sit in this pillar, and the integrator has to pass all three before the second pillar can be opened:

  • Door thickness. The lock's per-model door-thickness band — the published minimum and maximum thickness the lock body and the through-fixings are designed to span. For the SLK-9936S hotel-class lock, the published band is 36–100 mm; for the SLK-9905A hidden-reader hotel lock, the band is ~38–100 mm. Every other catalog SKU carries its own band, and the per-model band is what the supplier confirms against the per-model drawing — not what is inferred from a sibling model's published band. A door measured at 34 mm is below the SLK-9936S floor; a door measured at 105 mm is above it; a door measured at 36–100 mm is in band. The thick-leaf case (above the band's ceiling) breaks the forend through-fixings before the lock body is even seated. The thin-leaf case (below the floor) leaves the spindle floating and the cylinder unkeyed to the operating plane.
  • Backset. The horizontal distance from the door edge face to the centre of the spindle (or to the centre of the cylinder, depending on the lock's reference convention). Backset is the dominant dimension the door schedule has to carry; it dictates which way the lock case hangs relative to the door's centre line, and a door cut for a 60 mm backset cannot host a 70 mm backset lock without a new pocket. The integrator measures backset from the existing door's mortise pocket or from the door schedule, not from a template.
  • Edge geometry. The squareness, the flatness, and the finish of the door edge face on which the forend plate and the strike plate will seat. A door edge that is out-of-square by more than the lock's published tolerance shifts the forend plate off the spindle axis and the strike plate off the deadbolt path. A door edge that is cupped or bowed catches the forend screws at uneven torque. A door edge with an applied laminate or veneer has to be evaluated for the through-fixing grip depth the lock's screws will bite into.

The pillar produces three artefacts that run with the compatibility file:

ArtifactWhat it carriesWhere it lives in the file
Door-thickness measurement cardPer-door measured thickness in mm, with caliper reading, photo evidence, and a band-check verdict (in-band / below-floor / above-ceiling)Section 1 of the file
Backset schedulePer-door measured backset in mm against the per-model backset envelopeSection 1, sub-row under the door-thickness card
Edge-face condition noteSquareness check, flatness check, through-fixing depth note, applied-finish flagSection 1, sub-row under the backset schedule

Pillar 1 — at-a-glance checklist

ItemDone whenOwnerEvidence
Door thickness measured at three pointsEach door ≥ three readings; caliper tool of recordSurveyorMeasurement card + photo
Door thickness verdict loggedEach door carries an in-band / below-floor / above-ceiling verdictSurveyorVerdict column
Backset measured and comparedPer-door backset logged against per-model envelopeSurveyorSchedule row
Edge-face condition notedSquareness, flatness, through-fixing depth notedSurveyorCondition note
Below-floor or above-ceiling flag raisedAny out-of-band door flagged for routing decisionIntegratorFlagged row in schedule
Routing decision writtenEach flagged door routes to Pillar 5 evidence, retire, or rebuildIntegratorRouting decision note

The pillar's failure pattern is "passing the dimensional check by averaging." A door measured at three heights — top, middle, bottom — averages to a number that lies about whether the door is in band at every point. The pillar refuses the average; the band-check verdict is min-of-three, not mean-of-three.

Pillar 2 — Mortise pocket geometry

Purpose: decide whether the pocket cut the door already has, or the pocket the door-prep contractor is about to cut, fits the lock body the supplier is shipping.

The pocket pillar is where dimensional fit becomes pocket fit. The lock case — body, latch, deadbolt, spindle housing, cylinder cavity — has to seat inside the pocket without binding on any face, without floating proud of the door edge, and without exposing the latch or deadbolt path to the door's hollow cavity. Six independent measurements sit in this pillar:

  • Pocket length. The long-axis dimension of the rectangular pocket, measured from the forend shoulder line to the pocket's closed end. Out-of-spec length either traps the lock body sideways against the pocket end wall (lock cannot seat fully) or floats it proud with empty pocket at the forend.
  • Pocket width. The cross-axis dimension, measured from one long edge of the pocket to the other. Out-of-spec width either binds the lock body on its long axis (lock will not drop fully into the pocket) or leaves lateral play the forend screws are then asked to absorb.
  • Pocket depth. The measured depth from the door edge face to the pocket's back wall. Out-of-spec depth either leaves the lock body floating proud of the door edge (handle mechanism operates against the wrong reference plane) or sinks the body past the back wall (latch and deadbolt lose their projection).
  • Corner radius. The corner radius at the four pocket corners, which determines whether the lock body's shoulder geometry has a continuous bearing surface or a stress-concentration point. Sharp corners on a rounded-shoulder lock, or vice versa, are the silent failure mode that produces latch pivot wear after a few thousand cycles.
  • Faceplate cut-out. The width and length of the slot the forend plate sits in. The faceplate cut-out has to clear the forend, accept the forend cover if the model carries one, and align with the screw pattern the forend uses to mount the lock body.
  • Hollow-cavity exposure. Whether the door material exposes the pocket's back wall to a hollow cavity (typical of hollow-metal or wood-core construction) or to a solid section (typical of solid hardwood or poured composite). Hollow-cavity exposure decides whether the pocket's back wall needs a backing plate, whether the latch and deadbolt paths are sealed, and whether sound and fire ratings survive the pocket cut.

The pocket pillar hands off to the door-prep contractor's measurement clause library at Smart Lock Mortise Measurement (Smart Lock Mortise Measurement), which carries the numbered governance clauses for the pocket cut itself.

The pillar produces a per-door pocket schedule:

Door IDPocket length (mm)Pocket width (mm)Pocket depth (mm)Corner radius (mm)Faceplate cut-out (mm)Hollow-cavity exposureVerdict
(per-door row)per-model envelope value requested from the supplier, then per-door measured valueper-model envelope value, then measuredper-model envelope value, then measuredper-model envelope value, then measuredper-model envelope value, then measuredhollow / solid / mixedin-spec / out-of-spec / routed

Every cell in the measured columns is a per-door number; every cell in the envelope columns is a per-model number the supplier has provided in writing. The verdict column carries the integrator's hand: in-spec means the door clears pillar 2 and the door-prep work can proceed; out-of-spec means the door is held at pillar 2 and the lock body is held against the per-model drawing for clarification; routed means the door passes pillar 2 only with a documented remediation (backing plate, pocket re-cut, frame spacer, alternative faceplate).

Pillar 2 — at-a-glance checklist

ItemDone whenOwnerEvidence
Per-model pocket envelope requested in writingSupplier returns length / width / depth / corner radius / faceplate cut-out for the specific SKUProcurementDated supplier reply with drawing
Per-door pocket schedule filledEvery in-scope door carries a row with all six pocket cellsSurveyorPer-door row
In-spec / out-of-spec verdict per doorEach door has a verdictSurveyorVerdict column
Out-of-spec doors routed to remediationEach out-of-spec door carries a remediation decisionIntegratorRemediation note
Hollow-cavity doors flagged for backing-plate decisionHollow doors carry a backing-plate Y/N decisionIntegratorBacking-plate note

The pillar's failure pattern is "treating pocket depth as the only number that matters." Pocket length and width failures are more common than depth failures, because depth is the dimension the carpenter's depth gauge measures, while length and width are the dimensions a sloppy chisel cut can drift on. The pillar requires all six cells to be measured and logged.

Pillar 3 — Spindle, cylinder, and faceplate alignment

Purpose: decide whether the lock's operating components — the spindle that drives the handle, the cylinder the key or thumb-turn rotates, the faceplate that mounts the body — sit in correct geometric relation to each other and to the door's surface.

The alignment pillar is where the lock's internal geometry becomes the door's external usability. Three reference planes and three component distances sit in this pillar:

  • Centre-of-spindle-to-faceplate distance. The vertical distance from the centre of the spindle (the axis the handle hub rotates around) to the upper or lower edge of the forend plate. Out-of-spec distance shifts the handle above or below its intended elevation; an installer who works around the misalignment by adjusting the spindle square loses the lock's torque transmission and the handles operate at an angle.
  • Centre-of-cylinder-to-faceplate distance. The vertical distance from the centre of the cylinder (the axis the key or thumb-turn rotates around) to the same forend edge reference. Cylinder distance is what aligns the keyway with the escutcheon plate; out-of-spec distance either traps the key inside the cylinder projection or floats the escutcheon above the cylinder's actual position.
  • Spindle-to-cylinder offset. The vertical and horizontal relationship between the spindle axis and the cylinder axis. The offset is a locked-pair value on a given lock model; the integrator does not change it. If the door's existing cylinder cut-out is at the wrong offset for the new lock's spindle/cylinder geometry, the door is out of pillar 3 by definition and the per-model drawing has to be re-read.

The alignment pillar also carries the forend plate's handedness — whether the lock's latch and deadbolt hinge on the left or the right side of the door. A lock ordered for a left-hand door does not fit a right-hand door without re-orienting the latch, and some locks are non-handed; some are field-reversible; some are not. The per-model handedness the supplier confirms in writing is what pillar 3 reads.

The pillar produces a per-door alignment schedule:

Door IDSpindle-to-faceplate distance (mm)Cylinder-to-faceplate distance (mm)Spindle-to-cylinder offset (mm)Handedness (per-model)Verdict
(per-door row)measuredmeasuredmeasuredper-model confirmed by supplierin-alignment / out-of-alignment / non-handed-reversible

Pillar 3 — at-a-glance checklist

ItemDone whenOwnerEvidence
Per-model spindle/cylinder distances confirmedSupplier returns the two distances and the spindle-to-cylinder offset in writingProcurementDated supplier reply
Per-door alignment measuredEach in-scope door carries a rowSurveyorPer-door row
Handedness per-model confirmedSupplier confirms per-model handedness and reversibilityProcurementDated supplier reply
Non-handed or field-reversible locks routedEach lock's handedness rule logged against each door's handednessIntegratorRouting note
Out-of-alignment doors held at pillar 3Each out-of-alignment door carries a hold-and-clarify noteIntegratorHold note

The pillar's failure pattern is "the lock fits the pocket, so it must align." Pocket fit and alignment fit are independent. A lock can sit in the pocket with all six pillar-2 cells in-spec and still fail pillar 3 because the spindle/cylinder pair were designed for a different handing convention or a different forend reference. The pillar's job is to refuse the inference.

Pillar 4 — Door-material and structural compatibility

Purpose: decide whether the door material — wood, hollow metal, solid composite, glass-clad, aluminum-clad, fire-rated assembly — supports the lock body's mounting, the door's through-fixings, and any structural reinforcement the lock assumes.

The material pillar is where the lock meets the door's substance. Four independent assessments sit in this pillar:

  • Body mounting. Whether the door's edge material — typically hardwood, laminated hardwood, or structural composite — accepts the forend screws at the torque the installation requires. A door edge that is hollow for more than the first 12 mm from the surface will not hold a forend screw at full torque; the fix is a backing plate or a longer-reach fastener system, not a slower drill.
  • Through-fixings. Whether the lock's through-doors bolts (the fixings that pass through the door body and screw into the interior escutcheon plate) can be installed at the lock's specified length without exiting the door's far surface, intruding on a glass insert, or pinching a cabling pathway. The through-fixing length is a per-model number the supplier confirms; the through-fixing reach within the door is a per-door measurement the surveyor takes.
  • Reinforcement. Whether the door carries a reinforcement plate at the lock body location — a steel plate between the lock body and the door's hollow cavity that the forend screws bite into and that distributes the latch / deadbolt load across the door's height. Hollow-metal doors typically carry reinforcement by design; wood-core doors typically do not, and require an upgrade.
  • Fire / acoustic / weather rating. Whether the door's declared assembly rating survives the mortise cut and the lock body's installation. A fire-rated door assembly is a tested combination of door, frame, hardware, and seal; replacing one element of that tested combination voids the rating unless the new element is part of a re-tested assembly. The per-model drawing notes whether the lock is documented as part of a fire-rated assembly test; the integrator confirms in writing whether the specific door's rating survives the cut.

The pillar produces a per-door material schedule:

Door IDDoor materialBody-mounting verdictThrough-fixing reach (mm)Reinforcement statusRating impactVerdict
(per-door row)wood-core / hollow-metal / solid-composite / clad / glasssuitable / backing-plate-required / unsuitablemeasured reach, per-model requirementpresent / absent / upgradingrating preserved / rating re-test required / rating voidin-spec / out-of-spec / routed

Pillar 4 — at-a-glance checklist

ItemDone whenOwnerEvidence
Per-door material classifiedEach door has a material classificationSurveyorMaterial column
Per-door reinforcement status notedEach door has reinforcement Y/N/USurveyorReinforcement column
Through-fixing reach measuredEach door has measured reach against per-model specSurveyorReach cell
Fire / acoustic / weather rating checkedEach rated door has a rating-impact verdictIntegratorRating-impact cell
Backing-plate scope writtenEach door requiring backing plate carries a scope noteIntegratorScope note

The pillar's failure pattern is "the door is in spec, the lock is in spec, so the combination is in spec." The combination is what the pillar evaluates. A door and a lock can each pass their own dimensional checks and still fail as a system because the door's material cooperation — reinforcement, through-fixing grip, rating assembly — was never read against the lock's assumptions.

Pillar 5 — Per-model evidence

Purpose: decide what the supplier's per-model drawing actually says, and refuse to ship the lock against the door until the per-model drawing, the per-model envelope, and the per-door survey are all on file together.

The evidence pillar is the load-bearing pillar. Pillars 1–4 produce per-door measurements; pillar 5 produces the per-model source documents those measurements are read against. Without pillar 5, the integrator is measuring against an assumed template, not against the lock that is actually going to ship.

The pillar's input documents:

  • The per-model drawing the supplier ships with the lock, or the per-model datasheet on the lock's product page, carrying the lock body's dimensional envelope, the pocket cut dimensions, the centre-of-spindle distance, the centre-of-cylinder distance, the corner radius, the faceplate cut-out, the through-fixing length, the backset, the door-thickness band, and the handing rule.
  • The per-model quote confirmation the supplier returns in response to the integrator's RFQ, with the supplier's confirmation that the envelope numbers cited are current for the production batch the lock will ship in.
  • The per-door survey the integrator runs on site, captured by door ID, with every pillar 1–4 cell populated.
  • The compatibility matrix the integrator writes by overlaying the per-door survey on the per-model evidence, door by door.

The pillar produces the compatibility matrix:

Door IDDoor-side measurements (Pillars 1–4)Lock-side per-model envelope (Pillar 5)VerdictRouted to
(per-door row)all pillar 1–4 cellsall per-model cells, sourced and datedcompatible / held / routedproceed / re-engage supplier / retire door / rebuild

The pillar refuses to ship a lock against a door if any pillar 1–4 cell is read against an unsourced template. "Per-model" is the firewall. The SLK-9936S door-thickness envelope (36–100 mm) and the SLK-9905A envelope (~38–100 mm) are catalog-level anchors the supplier has published on the product page; per-pocket, per-backset, per-corner-radius, per-faceplate, per-offset data are per-model data the supplier confirms against the per-model drawing. The firewall's rule: numbers do not migrate between SKUs. A pocket length the supplier confirms for the SLK-9936S is the SLK-9936S's number; it is not the SLK-9951TH's number, the SLK-8831's number, the SLK-G200's number, the SLK-1104-class narrow-edge lock's number, or the number for any other catalog SKU. Each model carries its own drawing, and the drawing is what pillar 5 reads.

Pillar 5 — at-a-glance checklist

ItemDone whenOwnerEvidence
Per-model drawing on fileDatasheet or drawing received from supplier for the specific SKUProcurementFile or URL
Per-model quote confirmation on fileSupplier confirms the envelope figures are current for the production batchProcurementDated reply
Per-door survey completeAll in-scope doors have a complete pillar 1–4 rowSurveyorPer-door rows
Compatibility matrix writtenPer-door survey overlaid on per-model envelope, with verdict per doorIntegratorMatrix file
Held doors escalatedEach held door has an escalation note and an ownerIntegratorEscalation note
Routed doors closedEach routed door has a closure path (re-engage / retire / rebuild)IntegratorClosure note

The pillar's failure pattern is "the supplier datasheet says X, so the door is in spec at X." Datasheet X and door-side measurement Y are independent until they are compared. The pillar's job is to write the comparison and refuse the inference.

How the five pillars hand off to each other

The five pillars run in order, not in parallel, because the artefacts each pillar produces are the inputs the next pillar requires. Pillar 1 cannot open until the door survey is scoped; pillar 2 cannot open until pillar 1's door-thickness, backset, and edge-geometry rows are filled; pillar 3 cannot open until pillar 2's pocket schedule is filled; pillar 4 cannot open until pillar 3's alignment rows are filled; pillar 5 cannot open until pillars 1–4 rows exist and the per-model envelope has been sourced. The pillars run as a sequential qualification pipeline:

PillarInput artefactOutput artefactHolds the gate when
Pillar 1 — Door envelopeDoor survey scope, per-model door-thickness bandDoor-thickness card, backset schedule, edge-face condition noteAny door is below-floor, above-ceiling, or edge-out-of-spec
Pillar 2 — Mortise pocketPillar 1 outputs, per-model pocket envelope from supplierPer-door pocket scheduleAny door's pocket cell is out-of-spec
Pillar 3 — Spindle, cylinder, faceplatePillar 2 outputs, per-model alignment valuesPer-door alignment scheduleAny door's alignment cell is out-of-spec or the lock's handing does not match the door
Pillar 4 — Door-materialPillar 3 outputs, per-model reinforcement and rating posturePer-door material scheduleAny door's body-mounting, through-fixing, reinforcement, or rating cell is out-of-spec
Pillar 5 — Per-model evidencePillars 1–4 outputs, per-model drawing, per-model quote confirmationCompatibility matrix per doorAny per-door cell is unsourced against the per-model envelope, or any held door lacks a closure path

The matrix in the table above is the gate ledger. Each row is held until the artefacts are on file; each row closes when the per-door verdict (in-spec / held / routed) is written. A compatibility decision the matrix does not carry is a compatibility decision the file does not support.

The ledger is easiest to operate when the pipeline is read as a state machine: every door enters as a scoped survey row, moves through the five pillar states in order, and can only leave through procurement, a hold, or a documented routing back to the pillar that failed:

stateDiagram-v2
    state "Door survey scoped" as Scoped
    state "Pillar 1 · Door envelope fit" as P1
    state "Pillar 2 · Mortise pocket geometry" as P2
    state "Pillar 3 · Spindle, cylinder, faceplate alignment" as P3
    state "Pillar 4 · Door material and structure" as P4
    state "Pillar 5 · Per-model evidence" as P5
    state "Held at pillar" as Held
    state "Routed for remediation" as Routed
    state "Ships to procurement" as Ship

    [*] --> Scoped
    Scoped --> P1
    P1 --> P2: door-thickness, backset and edge rows filled
    P2 --> P3: pocket schedule in-spec
    P3 --> P4: alignment rows filled
    P4 --> P5: material schedule closed
    P5 --> Ship: compatibility matrix verdict logged
    P1 --> Held: door below-floor or above-ceiling
    P2 --> Held: pocket cell out-of-spec
    P3 --> Held: alignment or handing mismatch
    P4 --> Held: material unsuitable or rating void
    P5 --> Held: per-door cell unsourced
    Held --> Routed: remediation decision written
    Routed --> P2: pocket re-cut re-verified
    Routed --> P3: latch re-orientation re-verified
    Routed --> P4: backing plate or re-test closed
    Ship --> [*]

Per-model evidence firewall (no sideways transfer)

The five pillars produce their decisions against per-model evidence. The evidence firewall is the rule that holds the qualification program together: per-model numbers do not migrate between SKUs. The wall is strict for a reason — catalog SKUs share families, but they do not share drawings.

Anchor dataSKUSourceFirewall rule
Door thickness 36–100 mmSLK-9936SProduct page (catalog anchor)Cite the number only for SLK-9936S; never port to siblings
Door thickness ~38–100 mmSLK-9905AProduct page (catalog anchor)Cite the number only for SLK-9905A; never port to siblings or to SLK-9936S
All pocket / backset / corner radius / faceplate / offset / reinforcement / rating cellsAny SKUPer-model drawing or supplier reply (per-model only)Cite only for the SKU the supplier confirmed; do not port to any other SKU

The catalog family is large enough that a single dimensional mistake, ported across siblings, can mis-spec hundreds of doors on a multi-property project. The firewall costs one extra column in the matrix file. The cost of the firewall is much smaller than the cost of a pocket re-cut, a lock re-order, or a door rebuild on site.

Five-pillar compatibility scorecard (per door)

A compatibility scorecard is the per-door summary of the five-pillar qualification. The scorecard is the file the installer carries to the door, the file the door-prep contractor signs against, and the file the supplier's account team countersigns. Scoring rule: 0 = out-of-spec and unremediated, 1 = in-spec but with a note, 2 = in-spec and fully documented. A door scoring 0 in any row holds the gate; a door scoring 1 or 2 across all rows ships to procurement.

Scorecard row0 — Hold1 — Pass with note2 — PassScore
Pillar 1 — Door thickness in bandOut-of-bandIn-band but borderline (< 2 mm from floor or ceiling)In-band with margin(per door)
Pillar 1 — Backset in envelopeOut-of-envelopeIn-envelope with documented remediationIn-envelope as-shipped(per door)
Pillar 1 — Edge-face conditionOut-of-specSpec with note (cupped, applied laminate)Spec pristine(per door)
Pillar 2 — Pocket lengthOut-of-specSpec with remediation (re-cut or backing)Spec as-shipped(per door)
Pillar 2 — Pocket widthOut-of-specSpec with remediationSpec as-shipped(per door)
Pillar 2 — Pocket depthOut-of-specSpec with remediationSpec as-shipped(per door)
Pillar 2 — Corner radiusOut-of-specSpec with mitigation (chamfer or fill)Spec as-shipped(per door)
Pillar 2 — Faceplate cut-outOut-of-specSpec with alternative faceplateSpec as-shipped(per door)
Pillar 2 — Hollow-cavity exposureUnsuitable for reinforcementBacking plate addedSolid or pre-reinforced(per door)
Pillar 3 — Spindle-to-faceplate distanceOut-of-specSpec with note (door migration)Spec as-shipped(per door)
Pillar 3 — Cylinder-to-faceplate distanceOut-of-specSpec with cylinder relocationSpec as-shipped(per door)
Pillar 3 — Spindle-to-cylinder offsetOut-of-specSpec with escutcheon swapSpec as-shipped(per door)
Pillar 3 — HandednessWrong-hand, non-reversibleField-reversible with notePer-model handed(per door)
Pillar 4 — Body mountingUnsuitable materialBacking-plate scopeSuitable as-shipped(per door)
Pillar 4 — Through-fixing reachOut-of-specSpec with alternative fastener lengthSpec as-shipped(per door)
Pillar 4 — ReinforcementAbsent and not upgradingUpgrading with scopePresent as-shipped(per door)
Pillar 4 — Fire / acoustic / weather ratingRating voidedRe-test required and scopedRating preserved(per door)
Pillar 5 — Per-model drawing on fileNot on fileOn file, pending quote batch confirmationOn file, current for production batch(per door)
Pillar 5 — Quote confirmation on fileNot on fileOn file, partially completeOn file, fully complete(per door)
Pillar 5 — Compatibility verdict loggedVerdict absentVerdict logged with open noteVerdict logged, no open notes(per door)

The scorecard sums to a 0–40 scale per door. Doors scoring 38–40 ship to procurement; doors scoring 30–37 ship with notes the installer countersigns; doors scoring below 30 hold the gate and route back to the pillar that failed.

Per-door band routing (decision matrix)

The five-pillar verdict routes each door to one of five disposition paths. The decision matrix below is what the integrator reads against the scorecard's per-door row:

Pillar 1 verdictPillar 2 verdictPillar 3 verdictPillar 4 verdictPillar 5 verdictDisposition
In-bandIn-specIn-specIn-specSources completeShip to procurement
In-bandIn-specIn-specIn-specSources pendingHold at Pillar 5; supplier reply required
In-bandOut-of-spec, remediation definedIn-specIn-specSources completeDoor-prep contractor remediates; re-verify Pillar 2
In-bandIn-specOut-of-alignment, handedness reversibleIn-specSources completeRe-orient latch; re-verify Pillar 3
In-bandIn-specOut-of-alignment, non-reversibleIn-specSources completeRetire door; alternative SKU or door re-spec
Below-floor / above-ceiling(any)(any)(any)(any)Retire door; alternative SKU outside the band's terminal range
(any)(any)(any)Material unsuitable(any)Rebuild door; route to door-prep contractor
(any)(any)(any)Rating voided(any)Re-test assembly or replace door
(any)(any)(any)(any)Source missingHold whole qualification; supplier reply required before further progress

Cross-link map (how the pillars travel through the catalog)

The pillars above operate on every catalog SKU; the per-model evidence they read is per-SKU. Cross-links to siblings that carry the depth the pillars assume:

  • Smart Lock Mortise Measurement (Smart Lock Mortise Measurement) — the numbered governance clauses for the pocket cut itself; pairs with Pillar 2 and Pillar 4 of this article.
  • Smart Lock Door Compatibility Matrix (Smart Lock Door Compatibility Matrix) — the cross-model compatibility matrix; pairs with Pillar 5's per-model evidence discipline.
  • Smart Lock Door Preparation Guide (Smart Lock Door Preparation Guide) — the door-prep workflow the door-prep contractor runs against; pairs with Pillar 2 and Pillar 4.
  • Smart Lock Door Thickness Measurement (Smart Lock Door Thickness Measurement) — the door-thickness measurement protocol; pairs with Pillar 1.
  • Smart Lock Lock Case Measurement (Smart Lock Lock Case Measurement) — the lock case measurement; pairs with Pillar 1 and Pillar 3.
  • Smart Lock Cylinder Measurement (Smart Lock Cylinder Measurement) — the cylinder cut-out measurement; pairs with Pillar 3.
  • Smart Lock Strike Plate Measurement (Smart Lock Strike Plate Measurement) — the strike plate measurement; pairs with Pillar 2.
  • Smart Lock Retrofit Site Survey (Smart Lock Retrofit Site Survey) — the retrofit site survey lifecycle that owns the survey scope feeding Pillars 1 and 4.

Illustrative scenario — a 96-room two-population retrofit

Consider a 96-room property whose lock-modernisation program is splitting its in-scope doors into two populations: 88 standard interior guest-room doors (1–5 star hotel class, wood-core, 45 mm thickness, left-handed, single-latch-and-deadbolt) and 8 back-of-house service doors (narrow-stile aluminum-clad, 40 mm thickness, right-handed, single-latch). The procurement lead's RFP carries two shortlisted SKU families — one hotel-class mortise lock for the guest-room population, one narrow-edge-style mortise lock for the service population — and the integrator's job is to run all five pillars against both populations before either SKU is signed.

Pillar 1 outputs: 86 of the 88 guest-room doors carry a measured thickness of 45 mm, well within the hotel-class lock's per-model band — the band's floor and ceiling are confirmed in writing against the supplier's per-model drawing. Two guest-room doors carry a measured thickness of 43 mm, still inside the band but closer to the floor than margin; the scorecard logs them at 1 (in-band but borderline). Every back-of-house door carries a measured thickness of 40 mm, inside the narrow-edge-style lock's per-model band as the supplier confirmed in writing. No door is below-floor or above-ceiling; pillar 1 closes for both populations.

Pillar 2 outputs: the per-door pocket schedule is filled against the per-model pocket envelope the supplier returned for each shortlisted SKU. Three of the back-of-house doors show a pocket depth that is 2 mm shallower than the per-model envelope asks for, because the prior service-door lock was a thinner-body model with a different pocket depth. The remediation is a pocket re-cut on those three doors to deepen the pocket by 2 mm; the door-prep contractor scopes the work and the scorecard logs the remediation as 1 (in-spec with remediation). The other 93 doors are in-spec as-shipped; pillar 2 closes.

Pillar 3 outputs: the per-door alignment schedule is filled against the per-model spindle, cylinder, and offset values. Every guest-room door carries a left-hand alignment; the hotel-class lock is per-model left-handed; the alignment closes at 2 for the full guest-room population. Every back-of-house door carries a right-hand alignment; the narrow-edge-style lock is per-model field-reversible; the installer re-orients the latch during commissioning and the alignment closes at 1 (reversible with note). Pillar 3 closes.

Pillar 4 outputs: every guest-room door is wood-core and pre-reinforced at the lock body location, scoring 2 (suitable as-shipped). Every back-of-house door is aluminum-clad and pre-reinforced, scoring 2 with a noted through-fixing reach that runs shorter than the through-fixing length the per-model drawing asks for; the installer uses the alternative fastener length the per-model reply confirmed, scoring 1 (pass with note). The two guest-room doors with the 43 mm thickness carry a body-mounting note that the through-fixing grip depth is 1 mm shallower than the per-model grip depth, but the through-fixing torque passes installer-side pull-test; the scorecard logs 1 (pass with note). Pillar 4 closes.

Pillar 5 outputs: the per-model drawing and the per-model quote confirmation are both on file for both shortlisted SKUs, dated within the supplier's current production batch window. The compatibility matrix is written door by door across all 96 doors. 90 doors score 38–40 and ship to procurement; 6 doors score 30–37 and ship with installer-countersigned notes; 0 doors score below 30. The qualification closes.

The two structural observations the scenario carries: the pillars caught a 2 mm pocket-depth mismatch the dimensional-first program would have missed until installation, and the pillars caught a through-fixing reach mismatch the door-material-skipping program would have missed until the first doors were torqued. Neither observation required a re-cut fleet-wide; both observations required only three local pocket re-cuts and one alternative-fastener kit. The five pillars pay for themselves on a project this size; they pay exponentially more on a project that scales to 600, 1,200, or 3,000 doors.

What this guide does not do (out-of-scope, by design)

  • It does not assert a per-model mortise envelope. Every per-model cell is documentation; the catalog anchors held are limited to the SLK-9936S 36–100 mm band and the SLK-9905A ~38–100 mm band, neither of which generalises.
  • It does not score held certifications. No certification status is asserted or implied at SKU level or program level.
  • It does not publish prices, MOQs, lead times, or warranty years. The qualification program is a sizing and fit program; commercial terms are resolved through the quote channel at Request a quote.
  • It does not name properties, projects, or clients. The 96-room scenario is an illustrative scenario the framework runs against, not a customer record.
  • It does not migrate numbers between siblings. The per-model firewall holds across the entire compatibility discipline.

Closing — what to do next

If the procurement program is at the per-model envelope request stage, the next move is to send the supplier a written request for the per-model drawing and the per-model quote confirmation for every shortlisted SKU. If the procurement program is at the per-door survey stage, the next move is to bring the qualification scorecard to the integrator and run pillars 1–4 against every in-scope door. If the procurement program is at the compatibility matrix stage, the next move is to overlay the per-door survey on the per-model evidence and write the disposition per door. If a door holds at any pillar, the next move is to route the hold back to the pillar and refuse to ship.

The locks that ship to procurement are the locks the five pillars have cleared. The locks that hold at any pillar are the locks the program is protecting the buyer from.

The next step for the buyer who has reached the end of this guide and is ready to convert the qualification into a project is to send a written request for the per-model drawings and per-model quote confirmations to the supplier, then to share the qualification scorecard template with the integrator on site. The closing page for the qualification program is the project questionnaire at Request a quote, which is where the per-model envelopes become a per-model quote and the per-door verdicts become a project schedule.

عربة التسوق الخاصة بك
سيتم تحسين تجربتك على هذا الموقع من خلال السماح بملفات تعريف الارتباط سياسة ملفات تعريف الارتباط
Chat on WhatsApp