En 1155 versus en 1634 1 applicability: compare EN 1155 and EN 1634-1 scopes, evidence, and door applications to choose the correct smart-lock qualification.

نُشر في: يوليو 18, 2023

EN 1155 Versus EN 1634-1: Which One Applies to Your Smart Lock Door

EN 1155 Versus EN 1634-1: Which One Applies to Your Smart Lock Door

Regulatory brief disposition: Treat EN 1155 and EN 1634-1 as separate evidence tracks. EN 1155 concerns electrically powered hold-open devices for swing doors; EN 1634-1 concerns fire-resistance testing of complete door and shutter assemblies.

Decision owner: Procurement Manager, supported by the door designer, installer, supplier, and fire-door assembly approver where applicable.

Qualification question: Determine which function the opening requires before deciding which evidence belongs in the tender and supplier-approval file.

Qualification decision in one page

A conformity argument is only as good as its weakest document, so en 1155 versus en 1634 1 applicability is treated here claim by claim. For smart lock door qualification, the designation follows the function being purchased. EN 1155 enters the file when an electrically powered hold-open device is part of the swing-door arrangement. EN 1634-1 enters the file when the project requires fire-resistance evidence for the door assembly. A smart lock with no powered hold-open function does not become an EN 1155 product merely because it controls an electric strike or releases another device. Specifications at this level come off the smart door locks.

Direct answer. The short answer is that en 1155 versus en 1634 1 applicability is not one decision. It is a sequence. This article takes en 1155 versus en 1634 1 applicability from en 1155 versus en 1634 1 applicability through en-1155 to the record you keep. an en 1155 versus en 1634 1 applicability works as a two-column evidence test. en 1155 versus en 1634 1 applicability names the documents. Each column of en 1155 versus en 1634 1 applicability closes with a paper.

en 1155 versus en 1634 1 applicability is taken here as en 1155 versus en 1634 1 applicability, deliberately narrowly. It is a working definition of en 1155 versus en 1634 1 applicability. It is specific to this market and product, and it is not a statutory or certified term.

  • What the seller can produce — supplier declarations and drawings for en 1155 versus en 1634 1 applicability
  • What only an issuer can verify — third-party certificates covering the exact scope of en-1155
  • What to request — the document set that matches the SKU behind en 1155 versus en 1634 1 applicability
  • en 1155 versus en 1634 1 applicability runs this sequence, and en 1155 is the record it produces.
Buyer questionProcurement answerEvidence route
Does the opening include a powered hold-open device?If yes, assess EN 1155 for that function and its interfaces.Test report, certificate, declaration, and marking as applicable
Must the complete opening provide fire-resistance evidence?If yes, assess EN 1634-1 for the assembly, not for a loose lock.Assembly-specific test or supporting evidence
Is the smart lock itself being qualified?Add the applicable lock-performance evidence; EN 1155 is not a general smart-lock standard.Product-specific test evidence
Can one file cover both questions?Yes, when each claim stays within its stated scope and references the exact configuration.Two linked evidence tracks
Has a site been approved for installation?No standard alone establishes site approval.Conformity evidence remains CONFIRM-PER-SUPPLIER and installation acceptance is recorded separately

The practical answer is often both, neither, or one. Both applies when a fire-door assembly also uses a powered hold-open arrangement. Neither applies when the opening needs neither a powered hold-open function nor assembly fire-resistance evidence. One applies when only one of those questions belongs to the purchase. The procurement specification should state that decision before suppliers begin assembling evidence.

Why the designations cannot be used interchangeably

EN 1155 hold-open devices are electrically powered devices intended to hold a swing door open until a release signal is provided. The standard addresses that function within the published current edition. It does not test fire resistance, qualify a complete fire-door assembly, or establish that a smart lock works with every closer, frame, power supply and alarm interface.

EN 1634-1 fire resistance testing evaluates a door or shutter assembly under the published test method. Hardware is evaluated as part of that assembly. The resulting evidence must therefore be read against the tested configuration: door leaf, frame, hinges, locks, closers, glazing, seals, interfaces and other relevant components. There is no sound procurement shortcut in treating the standard as a standalone lock-fire certificate.

The standard also answers a different question from the lock-performance standard EN 14846. For the mechanical-electrical locking function of a battery-driven smart lock, EN 14846 is the closer fit in the available standards framework. EN 1155 becomes relevant when the opening also has a powered hold-open device. A buyer who uses EN 1155 because it mentions electric operation may miss the more appropriate product evidence.

Conversely, if the hold-open arrangement must respond to fire or smoke alarm conditions, EN 14637 may need separate assessment. Its scope addresses electrically controlled hold-open systems for fire and smoke door assemblies, including interface and power expectations. Its use does not replace assembly fire-resistance evidence under EN 1634-1. The current published titles and scopes remain the controlling references.

CONFIRM-WITH-LOCAL-FIRE-ASSEMBLY-APPROVER: Verify whether the opening is a fire or smoke door assembly, which assembly evidence and configuration are acceptable, and who approves the installed result.

Route the configuration before naming the standard

Start with a door schedule, not a product name. The same smart-lock variant can sit in different evidence paths depending on the door, frame, closer, hold-open mechanism, power arrangement and required release sequence.

Ordinary swing door with powered hold-open

Use EN 1155 as the primary designation when the procurement includes an electrically powered hold-open device. Require evidence for that device and define how the smart lock, access-control system or request-to-exit input releases it. If the smart lock only controls the strike and no powered hold-open device is present, ask the supplier for product-specific lock evidence instead.

Fire-door assembly with a smart lock

Use EN 1634-1 to assess assembly fire-resistance evidence. The lock is one component in a larger construction decision. A smart lock must not be presented as an independently approved substitute for the tested or otherwise assessed assembly. Ask for the exact assembly evidence and a component-change process that keeps the opening traceable.

Alarm-linked hold-open system

Where releasing a held-open door depends on a fire-detection or alarm interface, assess EN 14637 as well as the applicable lock and assembly evidence. A battery-only arrangement should not be assumed equivalent to a mains-powered system with alarm interface requirements. Confirm the intended release sequence and power-loss behavior in the approved project design.

Retrofit onto an existing door

An existing fire door, frame, closer and lock set create an evidence problem before they create a product problem. Use the EN 1155 When Retrofitting Smart Locks Onto Existing Doors as a survey companion, while the Smart Lock Retrofit Site Survey captures the physical conditions that must enter the qualification record.

Smart lock without a powered hold-open

If the opening has a manual closer and the lock is not intended to hold the door open, EN 1155 may not fit the purchase. EN 1154 covers controlled door closing devices, while EN 14846 is the closer product fit for electromechanically operated locks. Verify the current titles and scopes before writing either designation into the schedule.

flowchart TD
    A[Record door and required function] --> B{Fire resistance in assembly question}
    B -->|No| C{Is powered hold open present}
    B -->|Yes| D[Assess EN 1634-1 assembly evidence]
    C -->|Yes| E[Assess EN 1155 function evidence]
    C -->|No| F[Add product specific lock evidence]
    D --> G[Verify hardware and interfaces]
    E --> H[Verify release and power behavior]
    F --> I[Issue qualified specification]
    G --> I
    H --> I

Set separate document indexes after this decision: en-1155 for the powered hold-open track and en-1634-1 for the assembly fire-resistance track. Linking the indexes prevents an EN 1155 result from being reused automatically as assembly evidence.

Translate the inquiry into evidence-bearing specification clauses

A useful procurement specification identifies the exact question before it requests a familiar-looking document. Replace broad phrases such as “fire-rated smart lock” with the function, assembly and evidence needed.

Specification fieldBuyer wording to requestReason
Door and frameIdentify the door type, leaf, frame, swing direction, dimensions and existing assembly references.Establishes the tested or evaluated configuration
Hold-open functionState whether an electrically powered hold-open device is included and how it is released.Defines whether EN 1155 is relevant
Fire or smoke statusState whether the opening is designated as a fire or smoke door assembly and identify the applicable project route.Keeps EN 1634-1 at assembly level
Smart-lock roleDefine locking, authorization, monitoring, strike control and release functions separately.Prevents a hold-open claim from standing in for lock performance
Power arrangementIdentify the power source, power-loss behavior and any backup arrangement without assuming equivalence.Supports interface and safety assessment
EvidenceRequest named documents with identifiers, dates, scope, variants and issuing parties.Creates an auditable conformity evidence trail
InstallationRequire installation, commissioning, inspection and maintenance records.Separates product evidence from site acceptance
Change controlDefine who may approve substitutions in the leaf, frame, hardware and interfaces.Protects the approved configuration

Use the procurement specification to require traceability, not a preferred conclusion. A clause can say, “Provide current published scope references and evidence applicable to the electrically powered hold-open device supplied for this opening.” It should not say, “Provide an EN 1155 certificate for the smart lock.” The first asks the right question; the second confuses product and function.

The EN 1155 for Smart Locks: Scope, Tests and What the Standard Never Proves provides a useful companion when a supplier has presented scope language too loosely. The approved schedule should still identify this project’s door, interfaces and required evidence.

Separate the four documents that procurement receives

A standard describes what the standard tests. It does not certify a site, approve an installation or guarantee that every variant remains unchanged. Four document types are often presented as though they were interchangeable.

DocumentWhat it recordsWhat it can supportWhat it cannot replace
Test reportSomeone tested a defined sample under a published method.Evidence of the tested characteristics for the stated specimen and edition.A current certificate or approval covering the supplied variant
CertificateA named body attests conformity within a defined scope, with an identifiable number and validity information.Conformity within that stated scope.A test report showing every project-specific interface
Declaration of conformityThe manufacturer or importer makes its own legal claim for the declared product and applicable requirements.The party’s declared conformity position.Independent certification or assembly evidence
MarkingA market-access symbol such as CE, UKCA, RCM, KC or G-Mark appears on the product or label.Identification of the claimed market route.The underlying reports, certificate or declaration

Ask the supplier to label each attachment in the submission index. A product page image, a declaration and a certificate may refer to different products, editions or scopes. For fire door assembly testing, also require the report or other approved evidence to identify the assembly configuration relevant to the project. For a hold-open device, identify whether the evidence covers that device alone or a tested combination with the supplied interfaces.

Use this evidence-quality ladder as the commercial review sequence:

The evidence-quality ladder that governs en 1155 versus en 1634 1 applicability runs: marketing image → declaration of conformity → test report on a sample → scoped third-party certificate → certificate covering the exact SKU/variant ordered → audit and production-control evidence that keeps the result valid after the sample passed.

The rungs that decide en 1155 versus en 1634 1 applicability are the ones issued under en 1155; a file for a different scheme does not move the position on this ladder.

The recurring failure is approving at the second or third rung and discovering at installation that no evidence covers the exact SKU, variant, door combination or changed production process. A report on a sample is useful evidence, but it is not automatically a certificate for the order. A certificate is stronger only when its scope and identified variant match the purchase.

CONFIRM-WITH-LOCAL-MARKET-AUTHORITY: Confirm which marking, declaration and supporting market-access route applies to the exact lock, power supply and destination.

Control the interfaces between the smart lock and door hardware

Most qualification disputes occur at boundaries between components. EN 1155 evidence can address the powered hold-open function, but it cannot remove the need to verify the lock, closer, frame, power source and release inputs used with it. EN 1634-1 assembly evidence can address the tested combination, but a proposed smart-lock substitution still needs a controlled place in the assembly record.

InterfaceQualification evidence to requestApproval record needed
Smart lock and strikeExact lock variant, operating function and product-performance evidence.Configuration schedule and function description
Hold-open deviceEvidence for the current edition of EN 1155 where the function is in scope.Release logic and interface sequence
Door closerIdentification of the closer and its operating arrangement.Compatibility and commissioning record
Fire or smoke alarm interfaceEN 14637 assessment where the controlled hold-open system is in scope.Approved input, release and power-loss sequence
Power and backupSource, distribution, backup and power-loss arrangements for the supplied configuration.Electrical and functional acceptance record
Door leaf, frame and sealsRelevant assembly details and restrictions on hardware changes.Installation inspection and configuration record

Do not use generic phrases such as “fail-safe” as the entire specification. State the condition and required result: what happens after power loss, loss of the release signal, an alarm input, a forced-door event or a manual override. The supplier should provide the sequence it supports; the project designer should confirm that the sequence is acceptable for the opening.

Model-level electrical figures, battery duration, dimensions, read range and cycle claims must be confirmed on the dated product page for the specific SKU. The same rule applies to any claim about enclosure, radio or environmental performance. A standards file for EN 1155 or EN 1634-1 does not transfer those attributes to the smart lock.

Assemble the file by evidence strength

The tender package should let a reviewer trace each claim from the door requirement to the evidence and then to the installed configuration. A folder of disconnected certificates cannot do that. Use a claim register with one row per function or component.

Pack sectionMinimum contentRelease question
Requirement scheduleDoor type, intended functions, project classifications and named standards.Does the requirement match the proposed scope?
Configuration recordExact lock variant, hold-open device, closer, frame, power and interfaces.Can the evidence be linked to this configuration?
Product evidenceReports, certificate, declaration and markings, each labelled by document type.Is each document current and correctly scoped?
Assembly evidenceTest or supporting evidence tied to the relevant door assembly and configuration.Does it cover the offered arrangement or require approval of a change?
Production controlAudit, incoming-control, configuration-management or change records as applicable.What keeps the approved evidence connected to production?
Installation and maintenanceCommissioning, inspection, release testing and maintenance instructions.Who records site acceptance and future changes?

Use the EN 1155 in a Smart Lock Tender Pack: The Evidence Checklist to structure the hold-open evidence. Keep the assembly evidence in a separate index, even when both appear in one supplier package. The separation makes it clear which file answers which buyer question.

A missing document is not automatically a commercial rejection if the project owner can define an acceptable route. It becomes a rejection when a required claim has no traceable evidence and no responsible party will close the gap. Record the owner, action, due point and release consequence for each gap. “Pending” without an owner and decision date is not control.

Readers comparing approaches usually start with smart lock audit trail security. That is the same question en 1155 versus en 1634 1 applicability has to answer here.

Reject ambiguous claims before supplier approval

The Three Ways EN 1155 Evidence Disappoints Smart Lock Buyers describes evidence failures that arise when the supplied object is mistaken for the required object. The following claims need correction rather than passive acceptance.

  • “The smart lock is EN 1155 certified.” Ask which electrically powered hold-open device was assessed and under which published current edition.
  • “The lock is approved to EN 1634-1.” Ask for assembly-level evidence identifying the tested or evaluated opening configuration.
  • “It works with any closer.” Replace the claim with the approved closer and interface configuration.
  • “The certificate covers the range.” Require the exact SKU, variant, model or product scope to be identified.
  • “Battery and mains versions are equivalent.” Require the power arrangement and loss behavior to be compared at the function level.
  • “A declaration is the certificate.” Label each document correctly and verify whether independent attestation is required.
  • “The mark proves fire-door suitability.” Separate market-access marking from fire-resistance assembly evidence.
Ambiguous submissionProcurement correctionEvidence needed to close it
Product-page statementWritten scope statement tied to the offered variantDated product documentation
Generic certificateScope and identifier reviewCertificate covering the supplied configuration
Test report without specimen traceabilityConfiguration comparisonReport, sample record and change assessment
Declaration without attachmentsLegal and technical document reviewSupporting reports or attachments where applicable
Assembly claim based on component certificatesBoundary correctionAssembly-specific evidence and approval route

The aim is not to create a larger certificate collection. The aim is to make every claim answer one question and to prevent evidence for one boundary from being used at another.

Assign decision ownership and release conditions

The final en 1155 versus en 1634 1 applicability statement should name the decision, its basis and the conditions attached to it. A single approval owner may not have authority over every part of the opening, so the register should show who contributes to the decision.

This overlaps with the earlier coverage in smart lock access log security. That is the same question en 1155 versus en 1634 1 applicability has to answer here.

RoleDecision responsibility
Procurement ManagerControls the requirement, evidence index, supplier comparison and release status.
Door designer or project engineerDefines the opening, hardware schedule, interfaces and intended sequence.
SupplierIdentifies the exact supplied products and provides traceable evidence and instructions.
Installer or commissioning contractorRecords site configuration, tests the sequence and reports deviations.
Fire-door assembly approverDetermines whether assembly evidence and change controls are acceptable for the project route.
Local authority or other approving bodyProvides project-specific confirmation where the applicable route requires it.

A qualification disposition can be approved with conditions, but it cannot hide an unresolved boundary. Examples include a pending assembly-change review, a variant-specific document, a power interface confirmation or an installation test that has not yet occurred. Each condition must have an owner and a release gate.

CONFIRM-WITH-LOCAL-ACCESS-AND-EGRESS-APPROVER: Verify the applicable access, escape and egress requirements for the opening before accepting the proposed locking and release sequence.

Questions for the first technical meeting

A focused question set prevents a supplier from answering the wrong standard while still sounding complete.

  1. Is the powered hold-open device supplied separately, integrated with the smart lock, or absent?
  2. Does the smart lock release the hold-open device, control an electric strike, or perform both functions?
  3. Is the opening part of a fire or smoke door assembly?
  4. Which leaf, frame, closer, hardware and interface configuration appears in the available evidence?
  5. Which current edition of the named standard is referenced?
  6. Which document proves each claim: test report, certificate, declaration or marking?
  7. Does a certificate cover the exact ordered SKU or variant?
  8. What changes require a new assessment or approval?
  9. What happens on power loss and loss of the release signal?
  10. Which installation and maintenance records will close the site-acceptance stage?

Ask the supplier to answer each question in writing against the proposed configuration. A verbal assurance that the range is covered is not a substitute for identifying the scope. If the answer depends on a local authority or project-specific fire-door decision, capture that as an external condition rather than converting it into a product claim.

Draft wording for the qualification record

Use a disposition that separates function, assembly and evidence. For example:

The powered hold-open function is assessed against the current published scope of EN 1155 for the device and interface configuration listed in the door schedule. Where fire-resistance evidence is required for the complete opening, EN 1634-1 is applied at assembly level using evidence tied to the identified door, frame and hardware configuration. The smart lock is separately qualified through its applicable product-performance evidence. No test report, certificate, declaration or marking is treated as evidence for a boundary it does not cover. Certification status is CONFIRM-PER-SUPPLIER, and installation acceptance remains subject to the project inspection and change-control process.

Attach the door schedule, exact product variants, interface sequence, evidence index and outstanding conditions. Refer to the current published standard text for clause-level decisions rather than copying clause numbers from an old quotation or supplier template.

CONFIRM-WITH-LOCAL-DOOR-HARDWARE-APPROVER: Confirm the current editions, project specification, compatible hardware schedule, installation requirements and maintenance instructions for the specified powered hold-open arrangement.

Before quotation or supplier approval, send Smart Lock Factory the exact door schedule, intended hold-open sequence, power arrangement and candidate lock variant so each requirement can be mapped to the required conformity evidence before the qualification file is approved.

When the file is ready, request a quote against the written requirement.

عربة التسوق الخاصة بك
سيتم تحسين تجربتك على هذا الموقع من خلال السماح بملفات تعريف الارتباط سياسة ملفات تعريف الارتباط
Chat on WhatsApp